The v2 Forum
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

+13
laverfan
Diggers
Imperial Ghosty
Roller_Coaster
hjumpshoe
bhb001
McLaren
kwinigolfer
dummy_half
Stella
Fists of Fury
Rowley
MtotheC
17 posters

Go down

Please vote for the participant you believe has achieved the most in sport

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Vote_lcap31%v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Vote_rcap 31% 
[ 19 ]
v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Vote_lcap19%v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Vote_rcap 19% 
[ 12 ]
v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Vote_lcap5%v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Vote_rcap 5% 
[ 3 ]
v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Vote_lcap45%v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Vote_rcap 45% 
[ 28 ]
 
Total Votes : 62
 
 
Poll closed

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by MtotheC Mon 04 Mar 2013, 9:01 am

Today's second group.

Please vote for the participant you believe has achieved the most in sport

Please leave a comment as to why you voted.

MtotheC
Moderator
Moderator

Posts : 3382
Join date : 2011-07-08
Age : 40
Location : Peterborough

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Rowley Mon 04 Mar 2013, 9:07 am

Robinson for me. Both pole vaulting and rowing are a littel too obscure for a participant to be considered GOAT and don't feel comortable voting for a guy barely half way through his career. Robinson is the greatest boxer of all time in my opinion and there are none of the caveats that apply to the other guys.

Rowley
Admin
Admin

Posts : 22053
Join date : 2011-02-17
Age : 51
Location : I'm just a symptom of the modern decay that's gnawing at the heart of this country.

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by MtotheC Mon 04 Mar 2013, 10:13 am

Steve Redgrave- Rowing- Championed by ChequeredJersey

"One of the key features, in my opinion, for the GOAT in all sports is that a candidate must transcend his sport and attain significance and influence in the lives of people beyond the hard-core sporting fan-base. They should also attain dominance within their own sport. Many sportsmen (this term includes women too) are talented, some enough that they stand out above their peers. Far fewer stand out across the eras of a sport. Of these, even fewer are household names, celebrities or national icons especially in the ‘less popular sports’. Other sportsmen garner fame and celebrity status, but few of these can say they achieved unique accomplishments for sporting reasons. Those that fit into both categories and also manage to be uniquely great across a type of sport, not merely their own specialty, are incredibly rare. Sir Steven Geoffrey Redgrave, CBE, deputy lieutenant, is one of these. I will endeavour to show how in this article. Sorry that it’s a bit long, I got carried away…

If you ask a member of the British public to name an Olympian, chances are Redgrave will be near the top of the list. If you ask them to name a rower, I’d be amazed if he weren’t. He remains the only person to win 5 Gold Olympic Medals in 5 consecutive games in an endurance sport (as well as a solitary Bronze) and he adds 9 Gold, 2 Silver and 1 Bronze World Championship Medals from 1986-99 to that tally. He won his first Gold at age 22 and his last at 38, 16 years of Olympic domination in a sport that is based on physical strength and fitness, attributes that for a man peak in one’s mid-twenties. During the majority of that time, Redgrave’s crews were expected to win every race they entered and in a sport that has a number of strong competitive nations and is subject to conditions and how the crew clicks and other variables they nearly did win every race for nearly 20 years.

Non-internationally, he won different categories at Henley Royal Regatta, the premier sprint racing rowing race in the world, 21 times, the last one at age 39. These events ranged from sweep (one bladed) to scull (two oars) and from singles on his own to coxed 4s with a number of partners, as were his Olympic medals. The only constant was Redgrave. He also represented England in the 1986 Commonwealth games where he won 3 Golds in different races. I don’t know how many times he won the premier Head (long distance) racing event in the world, the Head of the River Race on the Thames, but he certainly did win it with Leander VIII and IV several times as well as his sprint victories listed here.

Most rowers specialise at rowing on one side of the boat – Bowside (starboard, or the right side of the boat from the cox’ point of view) or Strokeside (port). As well as sculling with 2 oars, Redgrave rowed both Bow and Strokeside and won Olympic Gold on both sides, testament to his technical proficiency (something very underappreciated by lay people regarding rowing) not just his strength. He was also renowned as a tactician and made the calls in his coxless crews and knew exactly when to wait and when to push another crew.
The only thing missing from his portfolio is a Boat Race victory, due to ineligibility.

He was also World indoor rowing champion (on a ergometric rowing machine) in 1990 and was British bobsleighing Champion and has run several London Marathons for charity. He did all of this with Ulcerative Colitis and Diabetes Mellitus Type 1, both chronic and debilitating diseases with severe health effects, both worse under the stress of severe physical exertion which rowing training entails more than most existent activities.

These are his considerable achievements within sport. Related to these, he has been BBC Sports Personality of the Year, won a Knighthood and a CBE from the Queen, a special pin from the Olympic Committee for winning 5 Golds in consecutive Games, a Thomas Keller Medal from the International Rowing Federation for his Outstanding International Career, has Carried the Olympic Torch in the Olympic Stadium at 2012 London, been the UK’s Olympic Flag bearer in 1992 and ’96, won Celebrity Gladiators, a BBC Sports Lifetime Achievement Award. He has set up rowing academies in India, raised millions of pounds for Charity, is an ambassador for Fairtrade and Founder and President of the Steve Redgrave Trust, and the vice-president of Diabetes UK and involved in many other charities. He is now Sports Legacy Champion and a Member of Sports Relief’s Steering Committee. The President of British Rowing, a Steward of Henley Royal Regatta and Vice President of the British Olympic Association and now a decade after his retirement is still the face of Rowing.

Since his retirement he has done so much for Sport and charity. He is a British legend who represents his country now as an ambassador. He epitomises determination, pushing oneself beyond the limit and the honour of representing one’s country. Inside his sport he has been a master and a mentor and outside of it a Champion for all the qualities we get from playing sport and all the emotion we suffer through spectating it. He is surely the inspiration for so many rowers, so many British sportspeople across every sport. He has touched many lives through the greatest of his achievements, people crying with him and for him. For all this, I propose Sir Steve Redgrave as the GOAT.
"

MtotheC
Moderator
Moderator

Posts : 3382
Join date : 2011-07-08
Age : 40
Location : Peterborough

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by MtotheC Mon 04 Mar 2013, 10:15 am

Lionel Messi- Football- Championed by Chris W

"It may seem ludicrous to talk about a man aged 25 as the Greatest Of All Time. Lionel Messi could easily have ten more years in football, and with talent like his he would have ten years at the top of the sport.

It's no cliche to suggest we are running out of superlatives to describe the Argentinean's performances. Messi is a magician. Young and old are mesmerised watching him at work, a player who has transcended the cynical modern critics, and brings back a level of excitement to the sport that many lose with age. People will watch Spanish football just to see him play.

Even the egomaniacs like Diego Maradona - “his potential is limitless and I think he’s got everything it takes to become Argentina’s greatest player"" - and Cristiano Ronaldo - ""Messi has his personality and I have mine. He has his game and I have mine. I also play in a big club like him. We are different in every aspect. But right now, he is the best"" - have had to give in to the brilliance of Lionel Messi.

The achievements are constantly stacking up. Leading Barcelona goalscorer of all time, four Champions League top goalscorer awards in a row, a Guinness World Record for most goals in a year (91), three Ballon D'Ors, an Olympic Gold Medal five La Liga titles, three Champions League winner's medals and many more.

In a team game, the contribution of others can be noted as one player achieves greatness. There is no doubting he is playing in one of the greatest teams of all time. But, quite possibly, without Messi they would be nowhere near some of the notable greats.

He is a one man sensation. He not only compares to the solo sports star, he eclipses them.

If he was Sampras he'd have won the French Open and won at least 5 more Australian Open's too.

If he were an opening batsman he'd average at least 70, and he'd be racking up 5 for's like he was owed one each game.

Whilst these one man bands have just an opponent to focus on, Leo Messi is a marked man who has players flying at him all game, a constant focus for every outfield player. He plays with a smile, never deceives the referee and never stops running at players, no matter how hard they hit him.

The one grey spot is the lack of international trophies, which must be a driving force to a man who only has Olympic Gold for his national side. To stick with the tennis comparison, the Argentinean side with their appalling defence, line of poor managers and destructive behind the scenes politics are like forcing Federer out on court but banning him from serving.

In a sport where the collective can restrict the achievements of the individual, Lionel Messi is standing head and shoulders above every man playing, and has the ability that no other man before him has had.

They said he didn't turn up in the big games, he couldn't play against English sides and his heading was weak. He scores a header against Manchester United in the Champions League final to clinch victory in Rome.

His weakness is the international stage. He has 76 caps at 25 years old, and 31 goals. Nearly a goal every two games, some weakness.

A boy who had to have hormone treatment as a teenager to help his growth, who was slated as too injury prone at the age of 18, has become a man that every player watches in a daze and no one wants to face.

Whilst much of this may seem trite, his brilliance is almost overwhelming. I cannot list all his achievements, I cannot describe every moment of majesty which outdoes the last. There is not the space nor time.

He's already eclipsed any individual brilliance of any sports star, and at 25 he has years ahead to widen the gap.

Youtube screams legend with every clip of the maestro.

Even in the modern days where to have been great in yesteryear appears to put a man on a pedastal that stars of today cannot match Messi is talked of as greater. In the world's most popular sport the man is head and shoulders above every competitor.

"

MtotheC
Moderator
Moderator

Posts : 3382
Join date : 2011-07-08
Age : 40
Location : Peterborough

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by MtotheC Mon 04 Mar 2013, 10:16 am

Sugar Ray Robinson- Boxing- Championed by superflyweight

"Let’s start at the beginning for the man almost universally recognised as pound for pound, the greatest boxer who ever lived. Walker Smith Junior was born 3rd May 1921 and following his family's move to New York, started boxing in a local Harlem gym. At 14 he wanted to enter a tournament and in order to circumvent the age restrictions (the minimum age was 16) he borrowed his older friend's Amateur Athletic Union card. His friend's name was Ray Robinson. The ""Sugar"" (a reference to his ""sweet style"") came later but from the moment he borrowed his friend's identity, a legend was born.

Robinson quickly went about putting together an outstanding amateur C.V. eventually racking up a record of 85 wins with no defeats. 69 of those wins were via knockout and 40 of those came in the first round. He was Golden Gloves featherweight champion in 1939 and then lightweight champion in 1940.

Turning pro in 1940 at the age of just 19, Robinson quickly went about making a name for himself, comprehensively beating current lightweight champion, Sammy Angott (who had refused to put his belt on the line) in just his 21st fight and then twice defeating (the second via a stoppage) the experienced master of the dark arts and former welterweight champion, Fritzie Zivic. A few fights later he won an unanimous decision against future middleweight great, Jake La Motta who outweighed Sugar that night by almost 13lbs (two whole weight classes in today's fight scene). Robinson was no protected fighter and fights against Angott, Zivic and La Motta as well as other tough, experienced opponents (including an ageing Henry Armstrong who is often regarded as the second greatest boxer who ever lived), represents a tough induction for a young fighter who was a relative novice. Despite this tough induction, it wasn't until his 40th fight that Robinson tasted defeat, losing a decision in his second fight against La Motta who outweighed him by 16lbs that night.

How did Robinson react to that defeat? He went unbeaten for the next 8 years winning 91 fights in the process defeating La Motta another 4 times along the way. Across their 6 fights, La Motta (who was a top drawer and very tough middleweight who would go on to win the middleweight title from the great Marcel Cerdan) outweighed Robinson by an average of 12lbs.

During that run of 91 victories, Robinson eventually won the welterweight title in 1946 at the age of 25 (boxing politics (in the form of the notorious Mob run, International Boxing Club) had kept him away from the title). Having amassed a record of 75 wins, 1 draw and 1 defeat, Robinson was allowed to compete for the vacant welterweight world title, triumphing with a unanimous decision over Tommy Bell. Finally, the man everyone knew was the best welterweight on the planet, had the belt that was rightfully his. Robinson remained undefeated as welterweight champion until he vacated the belt in 1950. During his reign he notched up wins against fellow welterweight great and future champion, Kid Gavilan before increasing problems making the 147lbs weight limit had Sugar setting his sights on the middleweight division.

Robinson won the middleweight title from La Motta in the infamous Valentine's Day Massacre which features prominently in the film Raging Bull. La Motta was stopped in brutal fashion in the 13th (the only legitimate stoppage of the legendary granite chinned, La Motta in 95 fights) and Robinson was champion at a second weight. Robinson subsequently went on a valedictory tour of Europe (fighting in various European cities against European opponents) which by all accounts was little more than one long party. Robinson turned up in the UK slightly worse for wear and somewhat undercooked and lost his title to Britain's own Randy Turpin having been outpointed over 15 rounds. Robinson immediately won the title back from Turpin, stopping him in the 10th round when behind on the cards. Robinson then defended the title a further twice against future champion, Bobo Olsen and former champion Rocky Graziano.

Having successfully defended his middleweight title, Robinson immediately turned his attention to Joey Maxim’s light heavyweight title. Against a very fine light heavyweight in Maxim and operating in a division way above his welterweight peak, Robinson was well ahead on all of the cards when he failed to emerge for the 14th round due to heat exhaustion. The fight had been held outdoors at Yankee Stadium in New York in sweltering heat and humidity and in the end it proved too much for Sugar. Following that defeat, Robinson immediately announced his first retirement from the sport.

Robinson stayed retired for 2 and a ½ years before returning at middleweight to take the title back from Bobo Olsen (via a 2nd round knockout) at the age of 34. His form on his return was patchy – he would lose the title three times (regaining it twice) but it was in this run of fights that contained Robinson’s greatest and perhaps most famous moment in the ring. At the age of 35 and up against the formidable champion Gene Fullmer (a man who had already beaten Robinson convincingly in their previous fight), Robinson was just about holding his own and then in the 5th round unleashed what many consider to be the greatest knockout punch of all time. Robinson hit Fullmer with a lightning quick left hook to the jaw which sent Gene plummeting to the floor. The fight was over in an instant and Robinson was middleweight champion for the fourth time. How good was the punch? Judge for yourself in the video below and consider that Fullmer had never been off his feet in any fight until that point and was considered iron jawed. Here’s what Fullmer had to say about it – “I still don’t know anything about the punch except I watched it on movies a number of times. The first thing I knew, I was standing up. I asked my manager, ‘What happened?’ and he said, ‘They counted ten.’”

Robinson would lose and win back the title once more and then would fail in a couple of more title challenges. However, he was long past his best by this point and pushing 40. Unfortunately Robinson (driven by a need to keep earning money) would fight on for many more years and would tarnish his record by losing to men who would not have been fit to get in the ring with him at his peak. This should not detract from how good he was. If we consider him only at his peak (generally recognised as being everything up to , but not including the Joey Maxim fight), he amassed a record of 128 wins, 1 draw and 2 defeats. Just incredible numbers made more incredible by the names on his record. Robinson defeated 10 Hall of Famer’s in his career; Jake Lamotta, Sammy Angott, Fritzie Zivic, Henry Armstrong, Kid Gavilan, Rocky Graziano, Randy Turpin, Gene Fullmer and Carmen Basilio.

The following description of Robinson is by Monte Cox and is taken from the excellent website “Cox’s Corner” and it describes Robinson better than I ever could:

“What other fighter could beat you more ways than could Sugar Ray Robinson? Ray could out box boxers and out punch punchers. He could do it inside or outside, going forward or backward. Ray could do it with his powerful left hook as he did against Gene Fullmer or with his perfect straight right as he did against Rocky Graziano. Joe Louis could throw triple left hooks with speed, power and accuracy that could destroy a man. Robinson could throw triple left hooks and triple right hooks that could do the same. Who else could do that and maintain frightening power?... Ray Robinson was the archetype of a complete fighter. If one combines his polished, grand boxing style with his powerful punching and cast iron chin with a will to win unsurpassed in the annals of boxing one has a perfect fighter.

“To sum it up, Robinson was the consummate professional fighter who possessed every physical asset; speed, agility, mobility, and tremendous punching power. He rates among a select few of the all time greats who could defeat fighters using their own best assets against them. Robinson, a true sharpshooter, easily rates among the best pound for pound punchers in history. Robinson is possibly the greatest combination puncher of all time. His quality of opposition is among the top five. Ray’s peak won-loss record is among the top three. Ray’s overall ring record and accomplishments also rate among the top three. Robinson is among the top five of all time in the category of longevity. Ray had all the intangibles, great experience, killer instinct, a tremendous chin and heart.”

Let’s finish by looking at what his fellow greats had to say about him:

“Someone once said there was a comparison between Sugar Ray Leonard and Sugar Ray Robinson. Believe me, there's no comparison. Sugar Ray Robinson was the greatest.""
Sugar Ray Leonard

“The king, the master, my idol.”
“That man was beautiful. Timing, speed, reflexes, rhythm, his body, everything was beautiful. And to me, still, I would say pound for pound...I'd say I'm the greatest heavyweight of all time, but pound for pound, I still say Sugar Ray Robinson was the greatest of all time.”
Muhammad Ali

Quite simply, Sugar Ray Robinson was the greatest boxer who ever lived and operated the peak of one of the toughest sports for a period of more than 20 years. He is regarded as far and away the greatest welterweight who ever lived (ahead of men like Armstrong, Sugar Ray Leonard, Tommy Hearns and Jose Naploles) and most observers have him in their top 5 middleweights. He had great talent, he faced and beat the best and he reigned at the top for an incredible period of time. In short, he was the complete sportsman!

"

MtotheC
Moderator
Moderator

Posts : 3382
Join date : 2011-07-08
Age : 40
Location : Peterborough

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Fists of Fury Mon 04 Mar 2013, 10:23 am

Robbo for me.

Fists of Fury
Admin
Admin

Posts : 11721
Join date : 2011-02-17
Age : 36
Location : Birmingham, England

http://bloxhamcricket.tumblr.com/

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Stella Mon 04 Mar 2013, 11:32 am

Yeah, gotta be Sugar Ray Robinson.
Stella
Stella

Posts : 6671
Join date : 2011-08-01

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by dummy_half Mon 04 Mar 2013, 11:44 am

Again, the revised draw making a big difference - SRR makes it through quite easily from this group.

I remain of the opinion that Messi, for all his talent, does not yet merit consideration in this company. Has he even reached his career peak yet? Maybe in 5 to 10 years he will be considered away and clear as the best, but not yet. My position on all active contenders is how would you rate them if they retired tomorrow? Messi simply wouldn't stack up in terms of achievement.

Bubka - fantastic pole vaulter, far and away the finest ever in what is perhaps the toughest event in track and field based on the combination of speed, strength and technique that have to be coupled. However, just too niche an event for him to be the GOAT.

Redgrave - Superb career, including but not limited to the 5 Olympic golds, but again in something of a niche sport (although not as narrow a niche as some we considered - it may be a minority sport, but it's a minority sport around much of the world).

So that leaves SRR - and now I have actually seen some footage of him fighting (highlights of his two fights against Carmen Basilio, shown on and ESPN Classics documentary). I understand he was getting old and past his best by then, but the impression was that he would match up well to the standards of modern boxing at his weight. And if he was better than that at his peak, he must have been something really special.

I'm not an enormous boxing fan, mainly because it is now about so much other than the competition in the ring, but from reading the write-ups on the various old time greats (Greb and Armstrong as well as Sugar Ray), I think I'd have been much more of a fan of these guys. As susch, Sugar Ray gets my vote from this group.


Last edited by dummy_half on Mon 04 Mar 2013, 11:47 am; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : typo - I like 'wimply', but not sure it's in the dictionary...)

dummy_half

Posts : 6317
Join date : 2011-03-11
Age : 52
Location : East Hertfordshire

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by kwinigolfer Mon 04 Mar 2013, 12:14 pm

Redgrave

kwinigolfer

Posts : 26476
Join date : 2011-05-18
Location : Vermont

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by McLaren Mon 04 Mar 2013, 12:43 pm

messi
McLaren
McLaren

Posts : 17491
Join date : 2011-01-27

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by bhb001 Mon 04 Mar 2013, 12:44 pm

That was difficult!! Robinson, it had to be, but Bubka was so dominant and still holds the world record, so I think he is very much under rated.

bhb001

Posts : 2675
Join date : 2011-02-16

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by hjumpshoe Mon 04 Mar 2013, 12:47 pm

Voted for Robinson. Redgrave is one of my sporting heroes but Robinson edges it for me.

hjumpshoe

Posts : 125
Join date : 2011-10-18

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Roller_Coaster Mon 04 Mar 2013, 1:45 pm

Robinson today.

Messi will get there I think but just hasn't yet.

Roller_Coaster

Posts : 2572
Join date : 2012-06-27

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Guest Mon 04 Mar 2013, 6:17 pm

Easily Robinson.

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Imperial Ghosty Mon 04 Mar 2013, 6:44 pm

After all my protestations Robinson has come up against the one person I cannot vote against, fully expecting a barrage of abuse from the boxing board but i've gone for Redgrave.

Imperial Ghosty

Posts : 10156
Join date : 2011-02-15

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Diggers Mon 04 Mar 2013, 7:02 pm

Robinson or Messi with the other two far too niche. Robinson I think, just.

Diggers

Posts : 8681
Join date : 2011-01-27

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Guest Mon 04 Mar 2013, 7:06 pm

There are probably a number of athletes with similar achievements to Redgrave scattered around a variety of niche sports. Most of us have probably never heard of them just as most of the world outside of Britain has probably never heard of Redgrave.

Robinson may not have the fame of Ali but he was a far more gifted boxer and his achievements greater.

Robinson for me.

ghost

emancipator

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Imperial Ghosty Mon 04 Mar 2013, 7:17 pm

That's the thing there's not that many with achievements that are similar to Redgraves, there's Birgit Fischer and that's about it.

5 gold medals in 5 consecutive olympics is a unique feat.

Imperial Ghosty

Posts : 10156
Join date : 2011-02-15

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by laverfan Mon 04 Mar 2013, 7:27 pm

Redgrave for me. Wink

laverfan
Moderator
Moderator

Posts : 11252
Join date : 2011-04-07
Location : NoVA, USoA

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Guest Mon 04 Mar 2013, 8:53 pm

Imperial Ghosty wrote:That's the thing there's not that many with achievements that are similar to Redgraves, there's Birgit Fischer and that's about it.

5 gold medals in 5 consecutive olympics is a unique feat.

I see your point.

But I'm not just referring to Olympic gold medals.

There are probably other comparable achievements in niche sports or less publicised sports, eg Khan's ridiculous winning streak in squash, or Phil Taylor's 1 million world titles. Most probably most of us don't even know they exist just as most others wouldn't know about the existence of Redgrave.

In fact going by this list,

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_multiple_Olympic_gold_medalists

there are around 28 Olympians who have won 6 gold medals or more. Are their achievements any less than that of Redgrave? Perhaps so because Redgrave did it over five consecutive games or perhaps not for it could be argued that rowing lends itself to longevity moreso than other disciplines.

Just throwing some thoughts out there. Redgrave, as I've said before, probably deserves a place in the competition, but I probably wouldn't place him in a top 16 and most certainly not above SRR.

ghost

emancipator

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Guest Mon 04 Mar 2013, 8:58 pm

Looking at that list, some guy called Edoardo Mangiarotti won 6G, 5S and 2B...

between 1936 and 1960 Shocked

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Guest Mon 04 Mar 2013, 9:00 pm

Doh How did I miss that

The guy above him won 7 Golds from 30-60.

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Corporalhumblebucket Mon 04 Mar 2013, 9:39 pm

Have gone for Robinson. Too soon to go for Messi.

Corporalhumblebucket

Posts : 7413
Join date : 2011-03-05
Location : Day's march from Surrey

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Hibbz Mon 04 Mar 2013, 9:49 pm

I've voted for Bubka because of his practice of beating his own world record to order. Also no one is currently getting close to said record unlike many other events suggests to me how great he was.

Redgrave is a conceited pr!ck and all the boxing fans telling us we must vote for SRR has swayed the contrary Hibbz away from him. Messi seems a decent player in the current age but time will tell for him.

Hibbz
hibbz
hibbz

Posts : 2119
Join date : 2011-01-27
Location : Right here.

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Diggers Mon 04 Mar 2013, 10:01 pm

Have gone for Messi in the forlorn hope the overrated oarsman gets eliminated.

Diggers

Posts : 8681
Join date : 2011-01-27

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Mad for Chelsea Mon 04 Mar 2013, 10:07 pm

Went with SRR.

Messi ruled out for much the reasons dummy_half outlined. Were he to retire tomorrow his achievements just don't stack up against the rest of the field.

Redgrave suffers from being a fairly niche sport (though I suspect some are being a little harsh on just how niche it is, quite a lot of countries are competitive at rowing).

Bubka suffers from being a fairly niche event, and impressive as his WRs were and still are, he also loses out from not always bringing his best to the biggest stage.

SRR is the greatest boxer of all time, so takes this round.

Mad for Chelsea

Posts : 12103
Join date : 2011-02-11
Age : 36

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Imperial Ghosty Mon 04 Mar 2013, 11:21 pm

I think people have the assumption that Redgrave as a british rower is only know in this country he is not, you read any article talking about the greatest olympians of all time and his name will pop whether it be australian, british, american or wherever. Being the only person to win 5 consecutive gold medals does lead you to end up with a fair level of notoriety in the sporting world.

Imperial Ghosty

Posts : 10156
Join date : 2011-02-15

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Diggers Tue 05 Mar 2013, 6:59 am

He may well be a great Olympian, but he happens to be a great Olympian in a niche sport where he operates as one of a team which IMO greatly enhances his longevity.

Diggers

Posts : 8681
Join date : 2011-01-27

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by super_realist Tue 05 Mar 2013, 7:46 am

Boxing is pretty niche. Very low participation levels.

super_realist

Posts : 28800
Join date : 2011-01-29
Location : Stavanger, Norway

Back to top Go down

v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4 Empty Re: v2 G.O.A.T Round 2 Group 4

Post by Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum