Barcelona Open 2015
+17
CaledonianCraig
temporary21
TRuffin
Haddie-nuff
lags72
HM Murdock
bogbrush
It Must Be Love
LuvSports!
Jahu
socal1976
Belovedluckyboy
CAS
sirfredperry
Born Slippy
ZZ
Matchpoint
21 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Tennis
Page 3 of 4
Page 3 of 4 • 1, 2, 3, 4
Barcelona Open 2015
First topic message reminder :
Draw: http://www.atpworldtour.com/share/event-draws.aspx?year=2015&eventid=425
Although Djokovic has been doing all the winning of late, the lead character in the current clay season scenario is still Nadal. He did better this year than last year in MC, reaching the semi and thereby moving up the ranking from #5 to #4. Would Nadal continue to gain momentum this week and win Barcelona? Hard to stay. To win Barcelona he'd probably have to defeat a very motivated defending champ Nishikori who will definitely fight very hard to recapture his earlier #4 place back from Nadal. Will the main attraction be the battle of #4?
Kei looked pretty good winning his opening match in straights. Good to see a non-Spaniard posing a real threat on clay for a change. Buckle your seat belt and stay tuned!
Draw: http://www.atpworldtour.com/share/event-draws.aspx?year=2015&eventid=425
Although Djokovic has been doing all the winning of late, the lead character in the current clay season scenario is still Nadal. He did better this year than last year in MC, reaching the semi and thereby moving up the ranking from #5 to #4. Would Nadal continue to gain momentum this week and win Barcelona? Hard to stay. To win Barcelona he'd probably have to defeat a very motivated defending champ Nishikori who will definitely fight very hard to recapture his earlier #4 place back from Nadal. Will the main attraction be the battle of #4?
Kei looked pretty good winning his opening match in straights. Good to see a non-Spaniard posing a real threat on clay for a change. Buckle your seat belt and stay tuned!
Matchpoint- Posts : 299
Join date : 2014-11-17
Location : Shangri-La
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Bogbrush, I've watched every game Nadal has played from 2013 to 2015, and if not anything Nadal now takes longer between points than he did in 2013.bogbrush wrote:Nonsense, they were ever going to enforce the rules while Rafa was at the top of the game. I think he'll get a much harder time now he's not the focus of the sport.
It Must Be Love- Posts : 2691
Join date : 2013-08-14
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Nonsense, they were ever going to enforce the rules while Rafa was at the top of the game. I think he'll get a much harder time now he's not the focus of the sport.
Isnt there another thread that has done this subject to death
Do you think you could air your views there.
There are enough negatives being discussed about Nadal this is only your opinion and nothing to do with the state of his game it is pure conjecture on your part.
Isnt there another thread that has done this subject to death
Do you think you could air your views there.
There are enough negatives being discussed about Nadal this is only your opinion and nothing to do with the state of his game it is pure conjecture on your part.
Haddie-nuff- Posts : 6936
Join date : 2011-02-27
Location : Returned to Spain
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
I doubt that. It's clear the sport has had enough of the cheating over time; just a pity it didn't come to its senses ten years ago and we didn't have to watch one hour 8/9 game sets become commonplace.
bogbrush- Posts : 11169
Join date : 2011-04-13
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Sorry, I thought this thread was being heavily used to discuss Nadals struggles. To my mind this is the leading cause.Haddie-nuff wrote:Nonsense, they were ever going to enforce the rules while Rafa was at the top of the game. I think he'll get a much harder time now he's not the focus of the sport.
Isnt there another thread that has done this subject to death
Do you think you could air your views there.
There are enough negatives being discussed about Nadal this is only your opinion and nothing to do with the state of his game it is pure conjecture on your part.
bogbrush- Posts : 11169
Join date : 2011-04-13
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
bogbrush wrote:Sorry, I thought this thread was being heavily used to discuss Nadals struggles. To my mind this is the leading cause.Haddie-nuff wrote:Nonsense, they were ever going to enforce the rules while Rafa was at the top of the game. I think he'll get a much harder time now he's not the focus of the sport.
Isnt there another thread that has done this subject to death
Do you think you could air your views there.
There are enough negatives being discussed about Nadal this is only your opinion and nothing to do with the state of his game it is pure conjecture on your part.
So it is but its only your view that it is the problem, no one else's. To me its another invitation to discuss Nadal's time violations.. he has more problems than that imo
Haddie-nuff- Posts : 6936
Join date : 2011-02-27
Location : Returned to Spain
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Is Nadal really just out of form? If so, did he just happen to be in good form every year from 2005 to 2014 during the clay court season? In the past, an out of form Nadal still scooped up clay titles for fun.
Not a huge surprise the Fognini loss, is it? I guess Ferrer could go on and take the title from here. Looking on wikipedia I make it 4 finals, all lost to Rafa. Looking for his 5th final here and 1st win.
Would I be right in thinking he has never won of the main tournaments of the clay swing in Europe (i.e. 1000s+Barcelona+RG). This could be his biggest ever clay win, on home turf?
After his 4th title of the season. He beat Nishikori this season already in a final.
Not a huge surprise the Fognini loss, is it? I guess Ferrer could go on and take the title from here. Looking on wikipedia I make it 4 finals, all lost to Rafa. Looking for his 5th final here and 1st win.
Would I be right in thinking he has never won of the main tournaments of the clay swing in Europe (i.e. 1000s+Barcelona+RG). This could be his biggest ever clay win, on home turf?
After his 4th title of the season. He beat Nishikori this season already in a final.
Henman Bill- Posts : 5257
Join date : 2011-12-04
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Ferrer did win at Valencia in 2008 when its played on clay.
Belovedluckyboy- Posts : 1389
Join date : 2015-01-30
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
I am of two minds on the impact of time violation clampdown on Rafa.
On one hand, Rafa has always been one of the worst time violators, so presumably he believed it worked well for him (I doubt the OCD hypothesis, in fact Rafa himself just about admitted to the more prosaic reasons for taking extra time). So from that angle it seems plausible that stricter time enforecement would hurt him.
On the other hand, I am not sure the rule is applied more strictly now than in 2013 (though I could be wrong), and he did just fine in 2013.
On one hand, Rafa has always been one of the worst time violators, so presumably he believed it worked well for him (I doubt the OCD hypothesis, in fact Rafa himself just about admitted to the more prosaic reasons for taking extra time). So from that angle it seems plausible that stricter time enforecement would hurt him.
On the other hand, I am not sure the rule is applied more strictly now than in 2013 (though I could be wrong), and he did just fine in 2013.
summerblues- Posts : 4551
Join date : 2012-03-07
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
I still have Rafa as the RG favorite. As others have said, the guy lost one match there over 10 years. He just about has to be the favorite until someone dethrones him.
Also, who can beat him there? Even in his current form, I do not see the likes of Fognini having a chance in a BO5 - especially not with Rafa fighting tooth and nail as I am sure he will be.
Other than Nole, everyone has to be a huge underdog in a match against Rafa at RG. I can perhaps see Nishi beating him if stars align and everything just clicks in his favor, but pretty much noone else.
So that leaves Nole. He might have a better than 50% chance in a one-off match but I also think that - their current form notwithstanding - Nole is more likely to go out early.
All in all pretty close for me between Rafa and Nole, but would still give Rafa the edge - and that is unlikely to change no matter what happens in Madrid and Rome.
Also, who can beat him there? Even in his current form, I do not see the likes of Fognini having a chance in a BO5 - especially not with Rafa fighting tooth and nail as I am sure he will be.
Other than Nole, everyone has to be a huge underdog in a match against Rafa at RG. I can perhaps see Nishi beating him if stars align and everything just clicks in his favor, but pretty much noone else.
So that leaves Nole. He might have a better than 50% chance in a one-off match but I also think that - their current form notwithstanding - Nole is more likely to go out early.
All in all pretty close for me between Rafa and Nole, but would still give Rafa the edge - and that is unlikely to change no matter what happens in Madrid and Rome.
summerblues- Posts : 4551
Join date : 2012-03-07
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Leave the time violation guff to the thread it was originally discussed in. Also take care in stating conjecture as fact
temporary21- Posts : 5092
Join date : 2014-09-07
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Rafa takes a longer time to get back his form this time because:
1) he missed his training block last year and only started training in late Dec,due to his surgery;
2) his stamina suffered as he didn't compete and train due to injury/illness;
3) he hasn't got back to his normal stamina level ye,t may need some more match plays;
4) he's older now so may take longer this time to recover; or
5) he may be in decline?
When he hit his prime and peak during 2008-2011, he did play well for most parts of the season unless he was injured, like during 2009. In 2008, he didn't only do well during clay season but also on grass and the HCs - 2Slam SF, 1Masters title and 1 final and 3 SFs and 1 Olympics title on the HCs. He finished the year 2008 being no. 1 on clay and grass, and no.2 on HCs just behind Novak. In 2010 he finished the year as no1 on clay and grass and no.2 on the HCs just behind Fed. In 2011 he was first on clay and second on grass behind Novak, though he didn't do that well on the HCs, he still reached the final of IW/Miami, USO and Tokyo.
I won't say Rafa was in good form just during the clay season, as he was good throughout the season during his peak years of 2008-2011 ( except 2009 when he had his injury). In fact Rafa was also doing well on HC and clay during 2012-2014, it's only on grass that he did poorly.
1) he missed his training block last year and only started training in late Dec,due to his surgery;
2) his stamina suffered as he didn't compete and train due to injury/illness;
3) he hasn't got back to his normal stamina level ye,t may need some more match plays;
4) he's older now so may take longer this time to recover; or
5) he may be in decline?
When he hit his prime and peak during 2008-2011, he did play well for most parts of the season unless he was injured, like during 2009. In 2008, he didn't only do well during clay season but also on grass and the HCs - 2Slam SF, 1Masters title and 1 final and 3 SFs and 1 Olympics title on the HCs. He finished the year 2008 being no. 1 on clay and grass, and no.2 on HCs just behind Novak. In 2010 he finished the year as no1 on clay and grass and no.2 on the HCs just behind Fed. In 2011 he was first on clay and second on grass behind Novak, though he didn't do that well on the HCs, he still reached the final of IW/Miami, USO and Tokyo.
I won't say Rafa was in good form just during the clay season, as he was good throughout the season during his peak years of 2008-2011 ( except 2009 when he had his injury). In fact Rafa was also doing well on HC and clay during 2012-2014, it's only on grass that he did poorly.
Belovedluckyboy- Posts : 1389
Join date : 2015-01-30
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
So stats wise (win % and finals reached) his best year was 2013. He was 26/27 for that.
So he peaked from 22-25. Off the peak at 25/26 but back in peak at 26/27?
Eh?
So he peaked from 22-25. Off the peak at 25/26 but back in peak at 26/27?
Eh?
LuvSports!- Posts : 4701
Join date : 2011-09-18
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
This Andujar v Ferrer match is good value. Ferrer hanging in.
Born Slippy- Posts : 4464
Join date : 2012-05-05
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
6-6 in the 1st set breaker, good stuff.
Give me a moment gents ive got an idea
Give me a moment gents ive got an idea
temporary21- Posts : 5092
Join date : 2014-09-07
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
temporary21 wrote:6-6 in the 1st set breaker, good stuff.
Give me a moment gents ive got an idea
You sound like Michael Caine in the Italian Job.
CaledonianCraig- Posts : 20601
Join date : 2011-05-31
Age : 55
Location : Edinburgh
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Impressive from Andujar to win the tiebreak from 2-6.
Born Slippy- Posts : 4464
Join date : 2012-05-05
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Too many missed opportunities for Ferrer. Andujar has the first set.
laverfan- Moderator
- Posts : 11252
Join date : 2011-04-07
Location : NoVA, USoA
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Not really seen Andujar play before. He is a very stylish player. Backhand is a shot of real quality.
Born Slippy- Posts : 4464
Join date : 2012-05-05
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
In my hotel room with no tennis on TV, so just following scores and do not see the play. Regardless, I was sure Andujar would drop the set after he failed to serve it out and then fell behind in the TB.
summerblues- Posts : 4551
Join date : 2012-03-07
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Looks like Ferrer may not even make final, unless he wins the next too sets vs Andu. Even if he gets thru, i don't think he's in form to overcome Kei, too inconsistent.
Matchpoint- Posts : 299
Join date : 2014-11-17
Location : Shangri-La
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Yes, he has some claim to fame, holding MPs vs Nadal during the Golden Swing. He was hitting as hard as he could and Ferrer put up mid-court balls on a few occasions during the TB. He has been pulling Ferrer side-to-side with excellent placement as well.
laverfan- Moderator
- Posts : 11252
Join date : 2011-04-07
Location : NoVA, USoA
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Hopefully my ideas better than CainesCaledonianCraig wrote:temporary21 wrote:6-6 in the 1st set breaker, good stuff.
Give me a moment gents ive got an idea
You sound like Michael Caine in the Italian Job.
temporary21- Posts : 5092
Join date : 2014-09-07
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
summerblues wrote:In my hotel room with no tennis on TV, so just following scores and do not see the play. Regardless, I was sure Andujar would drop the set after he failed to serve it out and then fell behind in the TB.
You should be able to use your computer to use WatchESPN and use your SP cable subscription login.
laverfan- Moderator
- Posts : 11252
Join date : 2011-04-07
Location : NoVA, USoA
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Vesley has a chance to a title in Bucharest. Monfils lost to GGL in three sets in the other SF.
laverfan- Moderator
- Posts : 11252
Join date : 2011-04-07
Location : NoVA, USoA
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Ferrer now bang in trouble. Is he feeling the pressure without Rafa in the draw?
temporary21- Posts : 5092
Join date : 2014-09-07
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Thanks LF but I am here computerless (with just a phone), plus this is a very different country so suspect ESPN might not work anyway. In fact it is just about bedtime for me now, so I will leave it to David and Pablo to fight it out while I am asleep.
summerblues- Posts : 4551
Join date : 2012-03-07
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Falzy, before I sign off, I am noting you kept your post but deleted my response. Of the two, my post struck me as less inflamatory, so I am hoping that whatever idea you have will include some further - and improved - handling of that branch of this thread.
I will see tomorrow when I wake up. Cheers for now.
I will see tomorrow when I wake up. Cheers for now.
summerblues- Posts : 4551
Join date : 2012-03-07
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
My response was edited by myself, and rendered your post unneeded and off topic. Asking to keep things in their thread is what I am supposed to do.summerblues wrote:Falzy, before I sign off, I am noting you kept your post but deleted my response. Of the two, my post struck me as less inflamatory, so I am hoping that whatever idea you have will include some further - and improved - handling of that branch of this thread.
I will see tomorrow when I wake up. Cheers for now.
temporary21- Posts : 5092
Join date : 2014-09-07
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Are those forum rules or just a personal opinion?temporary21 wrote:Leave the time violation guff to the thread it was originally discussed in. Also take care in stating conjecture as fact
Bear in mind the time violation subject (certainly isn't guff) was discussed elsewhere in the context of how annoying it is. Here we are discussing it in the context of Nadals defeat at Barcelona (and elsewhere).
bogbrush- Posts : 11169
Join date : 2011-04-13
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Rule 4, all three of us want to keep discussions from derailing topics. Theres a recent topic for that, and a new one just for this occassion.
Back on topic, Ferrer is hanging in... just.
Back on topic, Ferrer is hanging in... just.
temporary21- Posts : 5092
Join date : 2014-09-07
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
LuvSports, in 2012 Rafa had his injuries, how could he be in peak form??
Belovedluckyboy- Posts : 1389
Join date : 2015-01-30
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Poor Ferrer, the Barcelona title is not meant to be his. Andujar plays so well, I hope he can play this way in the final.
Belovedluckyboy- Posts : 1389
Join date : 2015-01-30
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Andujar (who?)
Matchpoint- Posts : 299
Join date : 2014-11-17
Location : Shangri-La
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Wp Andujar. A rose for Daveed, one day maybe...
temporary21- Posts : 5092
Join date : 2014-09-07
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Belovedluckyboy wrote:LuvSports, in 2012 Rafa had his injuries, how could he be in peak form??
That ignored the 2013 bit when he had his highest ever win% for a season and made it to 14 finals winning 10 - aged 27.
The point is your peak as a player and when you are most successful are not the same thing.
Also 2012 aus, clay court swing and FO. Good no?
LuvSports!- Posts : 4701
Join date : 2011-09-18
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Ninja will slice the Spanish Armada tomorrow, like a expired Jamón ibérico, right in the Barcelona, in front of their crowd.
Go Ninja go.
Go Ninja go.
Jahu- Posts : 6747
Join date : 2011-03-29
Location : Egg am Faaker See
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Could you direct me to it please? All I can see is one asking which of two players action is the most annoying behaviour. I want one where there's discussion of tennis.temporary21 wrote:Rule 4, all three of us want to keep discussions from derailing topics. Theres a recent topic for that, and a new one just for this occassion.
Back on topic, Ferrer is hanging in... just.
Edit: ah, excellent there's a new one!
bogbrush- Posts : 11169
Join date : 2011-04-13
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
LuvSports, I've to say Rafa is a bit unique in that he peak at different times on different surfaces.. He peaked early on clay, probably from 2005/6 onwards to 2013; peaked on grass from 2007-2011 and then went downhill. He started to peak on HC at about 2008 until 2014, I'm not sure is he declining on HC starting this year as he's just 4 months into his comeback from surgery.
I do feel that Rafa was at his physical peak from 2008-2011 when his speed and power were at their best, injuries aside. IMO he's not doing well on grass after 2011 because as he gets older, it's more difficult to do well at both the channel slams within a season. He may not recover in time for grass after his efforts on clay. It's just like Fed after 2009 couldn't go deep at both slams but could only do well at one, in his case at Wimbledon. Game wise Rafa is getting better even after his physical peak. Rafa is doing better at the HC slams because he has breaks for training and preparation before the HC slams, unlike on grass.
To summarize, Rafa was doing well on ALL three surfaces during his physical peak of 2008/2010, being no1 on two surfaces and no.2 on the third surface; and had it not for injury, his 2009 might be something similar to his 2008/2010. Had it not for Novak in 2011, Rafa might have won the IW/Miami combo plus Wimbledon and USO too, making it another 3 slams year!
I do feel that Rafa was at his physical peak from 2008-2011 when his speed and power were at their best, injuries aside. IMO he's not doing well on grass after 2011 because as he gets older, it's more difficult to do well at both the channel slams within a season. He may not recover in time for grass after his efforts on clay. It's just like Fed after 2009 couldn't go deep at both slams but could only do well at one, in his case at Wimbledon. Game wise Rafa is getting better even after his physical peak. Rafa is doing better at the HC slams because he has breaks for training and preparation before the HC slams, unlike on grass.
To summarize, Rafa was doing well on ALL three surfaces during his physical peak of 2008/2010, being no1 on two surfaces and no.2 on the third surface; and had it not for injury, his 2009 might be something similar to his 2008/2010. Had it not for Novak in 2011, Rafa might have won the IW/Miami combo plus Wimbledon and USO too, making it another 3 slams year!
Belovedluckyboy- Posts : 1389
Join date : 2015-01-30
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Rafa improved on hard due to practice and the slowing of the courts. I suppose 2013 would be his best year on hard.
He declined on grass due to his knees and the low bounce in my opinion.
Clay I think he peaked in 2008-2011 when he was an utter beast but he has always been good on it, until now.
Quite surprised to see Ferrer lose. I don't know much about Andujar but didn't expect that. I can't help but wonder if Ferrer is a bit of a bottler. When it's Nadal in the final he gets to the final all the time but when the draw opens up, he loses.
He declined on grass due to his knees and the low bounce in my opinion.
Clay I think he peaked in 2008-2011 when he was an utter beast but he has always been good on it, until now.
Quite surprised to see Ferrer lose. I don't know much about Andujar but didn't expect that. I can't help but wonder if Ferrer is a bit of a bottler. When it's Nadal in the final he gets to the final all the time but when the draw opens up, he loses.
Henman Bill- Posts : 5257
Join date : 2011-12-04
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
I beg to differ. My post (in response to your two sentence post) went something like this:temporary21 wrote:My response was edited by myself, and rendered your post unneeded and off topic. Asking to keep things in their thread is what I am supposed to do.
Re first sentence: please watch your language and tone.
Re second sentence: I do not follow.
This is neither inappropriate nor off-topic, so please restore it. If you want to delete, then please also delete your preceding post in its entirety (no editing or replacements).
Also, you still have not addressed my second point. Re my first point, you did edit out the mild swear word from your initial reply, so it would appear the best course of action on your part would be to keep my post as is and reply with sometyhing like "apologies, I edited out offensive language from my post" rather than use your editing powers.
Finally, your moderating on this thread appears rather inappropriate. Sure, one could argue that discussing RafaMs form is off-topic on this thread but a Rafa loss is bound to bring such discussions. Even more importantly, it was not BB who ventured into Rafa game analysis territory, you just seemed to have specific problem with his suggestion that the time rule could be the culprit, but not with other - equally off-topic - suggestions.
It would appear you are attempting to "moderate" the thread based on your personal preferences.
summerblues- Posts : 4551
Join date : 2012-03-07
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
SB, the argument that Djokovic is more likely to lose early at FO before facing Rafa...I always agreed with you before. This year.... I am not even sure about that argument anymore.
Djokovic record of avoiding early defeats is stronger than Rafa's at the moment.
Djokovic record of avoiding early defeats is stronger than Rafa's at the moment.
Henman Bill- Posts : 5257
Join date : 2011-12-04
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
HB, Rafa was already winning HCMasters in 2005 and I dont think the courts were slow during 2005. Also, in 2013 he was winning on the quicker HCs of Montreal and Cincy. The USO court may have slowed down through the years but I doubt Rafa with his big serve of 2010 and great movement wont win a USO title on quicker court. He's not winning many HC slams anyway, but winning the Montreal/Cincy combo surprised many.
Rafa's knees were an issue on grass, but to me a greater issue was that he had to put in more effort to win on clay these days, so he was poor by the time grass season started. Let's see with an additional one week break and with more practice, would Rafa do better this time on grass.
On clay, Rafa has also started his decline, from 2014 onwards I feel.
Rafa's knees were an issue on grass, but to me a greater issue was that he had to put in more effort to win on clay these days, so he was poor by the time grass season started. Let's see with an additional one week break and with more practice, would Rafa do better this time on grass.
On clay, Rafa has also started his decline, from 2014 onwards I feel.
Belovedluckyboy- Posts : 1389
Join date : 2015-01-30
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
US Open in 2006 was definately faster than recent years, not sure about the masters.
There is also the argument that Nadal would have adjusted his game successfully to an era of faster courts.
Is there any argument that clay courts are getting faster? Could that be a factor? MC looked fast to me this year. I didn't see any matches at Barcelona though. Like a lot of TV packages, I only get 1000 and above.
There is also the argument that Nadal would have adjusted his game successfully to an era of faster courts.
Is there any argument that clay courts are getting faster? Could that be a factor? MC looked fast to me this year. I didn't see any matches at Barcelona though. Like a lot of TV packages, I only get 1000 and above.
Henman Bill- Posts : 5257
Join date : 2011-12-04
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
The fastest clay are apparently madrid and Sao Paulo.
MC is always quite slow.
MC is always quite slow.
LuvSports!- Posts : 4701
Join date : 2011-09-18
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Rafa could win on fast clay; he had been winning at Madrid or reaching the finals since it was played on clay starting from 2009, with the exception of slippery blue clay in 2012. He won three out of five played on red clay.
MC looked a bit quick this year, but thats not the reason Rafa lost.
MC looked a bit quick this year, but thats not the reason Rafa lost.
Belovedluckyboy- Posts : 1389
Join date : 2015-01-30
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
The last thing Rafa wants now is super-slow clay.
bogbrush- Posts : 11169
Join date : 2011-04-13
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Surprisingly, Rafa's records at the slower HCs aren't as good as his records on the relatively quicker courts. Other than IW with the high bounces where Rafa won three titles, he wasn't any successful at Miami which was one of the slowest HCs around.
Rafa only managed 4 on slow HCs - 3 Iw and 1 AO. He had 8 on quicker HCs - 1 Madrid indoors, 1 Dubai, 1 Tokyo, 1 Beijing Open in 2005, 1 Beijing Olympics, 2 Montreal and 1 Cincy. I consider Toronto of medium speed, quicker than IW/Miami but slower than Montreal and Cincy. So Rafa has 4 on medium speed HCs - 1 Doha, 1 Toronto and 2 USO.
Hes not as good as Fed, Novak and Murray on the HCs imo, so winning three HC slams and finishing one season as tied no.1 on HCs (in 2009 won AO and tied with Novak as no.1) and 2nd on HCs in 2008/2010/2013 are not bad results for him.
Rafa only managed 4 on slow HCs - 3 Iw and 1 AO. He had 8 on quicker HCs - 1 Madrid indoors, 1 Dubai, 1 Tokyo, 1 Beijing Open in 2005, 1 Beijing Olympics, 2 Montreal and 1 Cincy. I consider Toronto of medium speed, quicker than IW/Miami but slower than Montreal and Cincy. So Rafa has 4 on medium speed HCs - 1 Doha, 1 Toronto and 2 USO.
Hes not as good as Fed, Novak and Murray on the HCs imo, so winning three HC slams and finishing one season as tied no.1 on HCs (in 2009 won AO and tied with Novak as no.1) and 2nd on HCs in 2008/2010/2013 are not bad results for him.
Belovedluckyboy- Posts : 1389
Join date : 2015-01-30
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
The reason for all the Rafa talk is given in the new thread. Refer to that for your answer. The original wording was edited which made both points of your comment unneeded, as is your reply. I have easily allowed discussion of all topics you say I don't like, all that's been done us put them in their own topics, no discussion is being stopped.summerblues wrote:I beg to differ. My post (in response to your two sentence post) went something like this:temporary21 wrote:My response was edited by myself, and rendered your post unneeded and off topic. Asking to keep things in their thread is what I am supposed to do.
Re first sentence: please watch your language and tone.
Re second sentence: I do not follow.
This is neither inappropriate nor off-topic, so please restore it. If you want to delete, then please also delete your preceding post in its entirety (no editing or replacements).
Also, you still have not addressed my second point. Re my first point, you did edit out the mild swear word from your initial reply, so it would appear the best course of action on your part would be to keep my post as is and reply with sometyhing like "apologies, I edited out offensive language from my post" rather than use your editing powers.
Finally, your moderating on this thread appears rather inappropriate. Sure, one could argue that discussing RafaMs form is off-topic on this thread but a Rafa loss is bound to bring such discussions. Even more importantly, it was not BB who ventured into Rafa game analysis territory, you just seemed to have specific problem with his suggestion that the time rule could be the culprit, but not with other - equally off-topic - suggestions.
It would appear you are attempting to "moderate" the thread based on your personal preferences.
temporary21- Posts : 5092
Join date : 2014-09-07
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
Kei vs Andujar, I think Kei is too strong for Andujar. I doubt Andujar could continue with his winning momentum, Kei is simply playing some brilliant tennis at the moment. Looks like he's going to retain his crown here.
Belovedluckyboy- Posts : 1389
Join date : 2015-01-30
Re: Barcelona Open 2015
...and possibly get the FO too
Jahu- Posts : 6747
Join date : 2011-03-29
Location : Egg am Faaker See
Page 3 of 4 • 1, 2, 3, 4
Similar topics
» French Open 2015 - Day 9
» Who will win Barcelona Open ?
» ATP 500 - Barcelona Open: The Final
» 606v2 ATP Picking Game: Barcelona Open
» French Open 2015 - Day 8
» Who will win Barcelona Open ?
» ATP 500 - Barcelona Open: The Final
» 606v2 ATP Picking Game: Barcelona Open
» French Open 2015 - Day 8
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Tennis
Page 3 of 4
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|