Lions crash test dummy
+7
tigertattie
Cyril
EST
TJ
IanBru
Shifty
poissonrouge
11 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: International
Page 1 of 1
Lions crash test dummy
There has been a bit of discussion on the Ireland England game thread about Jonny Sexton being in the firing line - in fact it was confirmed that he was "targeted" by England (Link to Mail article) and previously he was singled out for special attention by France.
Which got me thinking - what is the best option for Lions flyhalf against the All Blacks. Conventional thinking might suggest that you pick the most skilled player, but should other factors be involved in the decision? The All Blacks are known to be uncompromising in their pursuit of victory, and surely they as England did, would consider whether it would be profitable to "disrupt the 9 and 10s rhythm" as Launchbury refers to.?
There are a few names floating around for possibly filling the flyhalf position, but do we need to consider their durability as well as their skill. A list follows with some comments on suitability for filling the position of crash test dummy for the Lions.
Jonny Sexton - hard as iron nails, but is there a risk of metal fatigue?
Finn Russell - this is the one who has to strap a mini pillow to his forehead
George Ford - Looks a bit small to me.
Owen Farrell - From rugby league stock - teak tough and looks it.
So on balance - maybe Farrell is the one Gatland should be pinning the target to, as to me he looks the best bet to stand up to a bit of All Black fly(half) swatting?
Which got me thinking - what is the best option for Lions flyhalf against the All Blacks. Conventional thinking might suggest that you pick the most skilled player, but should other factors be involved in the decision? The All Blacks are known to be uncompromising in their pursuit of victory, and surely they as England did, would consider whether it would be profitable to "disrupt the 9 and 10s rhythm" as Launchbury refers to.?
There are a few names floating around for possibly filling the flyhalf position, but do we need to consider their durability as well as their skill. A list follows with some comments on suitability for filling the position of crash test dummy for the Lions.
Jonny Sexton - hard as iron nails, but is there a risk of metal fatigue?
Finn Russell - this is the one who has to strap a mini pillow to his forehead
George Ford - Looks a bit small to me.
Owen Farrell - From rugby league stock - teak tough and looks it.
So on balance - maybe Farrell is the one Gatland should be pinning the target to, as to me he looks the best bet to stand up to a bit of All Black fly(half) swatting?
poissonrouge- Posts : 525
Join date : 2011-05-24
Location : Belfast
Re: Lions crash test dummy
I think Biggar and Farrell are to basic and won't get the line moving, New Zealand WILL score tries and if we don't then it will be another duffing in New Zealand for the Lions.
Having a small fly half is fine provided he isn't the first line of defense. IF we can look after him in the way Ireland always looked Ronan O'Gara then we'll be fine. Personally I expect Warburton to be given the blind side flanker role and stay on his shoulder in defense to prevent him being targeted.
I think Sexton is in the driving seat myself.
Having a small fly half is fine provided he isn't the first line of defense. IF we can look after him in the way Ireland always looked Ronan O'Gara then we'll be fine. Personally I expect Warburton to be given the blind side flanker role and stay on his shoulder in defense to prevent him being targeted.
I think Sexton is in the driving seat myself.
Shifty- Posts : 7393
Join date : 2011-04-26
Age : 44
Location : Kenfig Hill, Bridgend
Re: Lions crash test dummy
I share your worries that players will be targeted. We need only look back to 2005 to find examples! That being said, we won’t win by picking the most durable player, we win by fronting up and matching the ABs punch-for-punch. As it happens, I'd pick Farrell at 10 anyway.
I think it’s time to dust off the old ‘99’ call or, adjusted for inflation, the ‘947’ call…
I think it’s time to dust off the old ‘99’ call or, adjusted for inflation, the ‘947’ call…
IanBru- Posts : 2909
Join date : 2011-04-30
Age : 35
Location : Newcastle
Re: Lions crash test dummy
I think Sexton would cope better than Farrell with being targeted because of his temperament and because he can move the ball on quicker
TJ- Posts : 8523
Join date : 2013-09-22
Re: Lions crash test dummy
AS for targeting players - every team does that. Pick out the weak link or the hot head and try to put them off / make them lose their temper
TJ- Posts : 8523
Join date : 2013-09-22
Re: Lions crash test dummy
poissonrouge wrote:There has been a bit of discussion on the Ireland England game thread about Jonny Sexton being in the firing line - in fact it was confirmed that he was "targeted" by England (Link to Mail article) and previously he was singled out for special attention by France.
Which got me thinking - what is the best option for Lions flyhalf against the All Blacks. Conventional thinking might suggest that you pick the most skilled player, but should other factors be involved in the decision? The All Blacks are known to be uncompromising in their pursuit of victory, and surely they as England did, would consider whether it would be profitable to "disrupt the 9 and 10s rhythm" as Launchbury refers to.?
There are a few names floating around for possibly filling the flyhalf position, but do we need to consider their durability as well as their skill. A list follows with some comments on suitability for filling the position of crash test dummy for the Lions.
Jonny Sexton - hard as iron nails, but is there a risk of metal fatigue?
Finn Russell - this is the one who has to strap a mini pillow to his forehead
George Ford - Looks a bit small to me.
Owen Farrell - From rugby league stock - teak tough and looks it.
So on balance - maybe Farrell is the one Gatland should be pinning the target to, as to me he looks the best bet to stand up to a bit of All Black fly(half) swatting?
He does that because he suffered a very significant head injury last season, not because of any unwillingness to engage in the physical stuff.
The best player should start at ten, so it's Sexton for me.
EST- Posts : 1905
Join date : 2012-05-25
Re: Lions crash test dummy
The pillow comment was a lighthearted one - I am not in any way criticising Russell for any failure to engage merely pointing out that as you say he got a really bad whack last year and maybe (just as with Jonny Sexton) it might be better to put someone else in the firing line!He does that because he suffered a very significant head injury last season, not because of any unwillingness to engage in the physical stuff.
And the whole thread is a bit tongue in cheek anyway - I think Sexton is probably the best bet for 10 (with Farrell at 12 as a dual playmaker maybe), although I do worry a bit about Sextons long term health - I take the point about Ireland protecting ROG in the old days but somehow - whether it is a change in the way the game is played or a masochistic streak on Sextons part - it doesn't seem that easy to protect Jonny
poissonrouge- Posts : 525
Join date : 2011-05-24
Location : Belfast
Re: Lions crash test dummy
Sexton at 10 with Farrell at 12. I'd love to see that partnership.
Farrell to move to 10 if/when NZ 'do a BOD' on Sexton.
Farrell to move to 10 if/when NZ 'do a BOD' on Sexton.
Cyril- Posts : 7162
Join date : 2012-11-16
Re: Lions crash test dummy
That's what I am worried about!!Farrell to move to 10 if/when NZ 'do a BOD' on Sexton.
poissonrouge- Posts : 525
Join date : 2011-05-24
Location : Belfast
Re: Lions crash test dummy
poissonrouge wrote:The pillow comment was a lighthearted one - I am not in any way criticising Russell for any failure to engage merely pointing out that as you say he got a really bad whack last year and maybe (just as with Jonny Sexton) it might be better to put someone else in the firing line!He does that because he suffered a very significant head injury last season, not because of any unwillingness to engage in the physical stuff.
And the whole thread is a bit tongue in cheek anyway - I think Sexton is probably the best bet for 10 (with Farrell at 12 as a dual playmaker maybe), although I do worry a bit about Sextons long term health - I take the point about Ireland protecting ROG in the old days but somehow - whether it is a change in the way the game is played or a masochistic streak on Sextons part - it doesn't seem that easy to protect Jonny
Gotya, got the wrong end of the stick there.
Yeah, a Sexton and Farrell combination for me with one of Joseph or Ringrose looks good to me.
EST- Posts : 1905
Join date : 2012-05-25
Re: Lions crash test dummy
Shifty wrote:I think Biggar and Farrell are to basic and won't get the line moving, New Zealand WILL score tries and if we don't then it will be another duffing in New Zealand for the Lions.
Having a small fly half is fine provided he isn't the first line of defense. IF we can look after him in the way Ireland always looked Ronan O'Gara then we'll be fine. Personally I expect Warburton to be given the blind side flanker role and stay on his shoulder in defense to prevent him being targeted.
I think Sexton is in the driving seat myself.
Isn't the openside flank going to be more responsible for looking after the 10?
besides, the reason that Sexton is targeted is because without him, Ireland aren't anywhere near as threatening. Most teams will "target" the 9 or 10 as they dictate the plays and control the game. If you pressurize them, you force them not to play the game they want to! This is why Scotland are either hot or cold as Russell is prone to getting frustrated when pressured!
tigertattie- Posts : 9499
Join date : 2011-07-11
Location : On the naughty step
Re: Lions crash test dummy
England's clear and unsportsmanlike targeting of Sexton was just another sign of a poor weekend for the integrity of Rugby Union. What with the blatant cheating by the French, biting and treatment of Sexton it reminds me that this is a sport where some think ti is okay to use fake blood.
Gwlad- Posts : 4224
Join date : 2014-12-04
Re: Lions crash test dummy
Luckily Dan Biggar would never scream in a ref's face and jump up and down like a kid having a tantrum, eh? Model proGwlad wrote:England's clear and unsportsmanlike targeting of Sexton was just another sign of a poor weekend for the integrity of Rugby Union. What with the blatant cheating by the French, biting and treatment of Sexton it reminds me that this is a sport where some think ti is okay to use fake blood.
Cyril- Posts : 7162
Join date : 2012-11-16
Re: Lions crash test dummy
Cyril wrote:Luckily Dan Biggar would never scream in a ref's face and jump up and down like a kid having a tantrum, eh? Model proGwlad wrote:England's clear and unsportsmanlike targeting of Sexton was just another sign of a poor weekend for the integrity of Rugby Union. What with the blatant cheating by the French, biting and treatment of Sexton it reminds me that this is a sport where some think ti is okay to use fake blood.
Yeah he modeled himself on Farrell.
Gwlad- Posts : 4224
Join date : 2014-12-04
Re: Lions crash test dummy
Its unsurprising that Biggar would aspire to be like Owen Farrell, given the latter's quality
BamBam- Posts : 17226
Join date : 2011-03-17
Age : 34
Re: Lions crash test dummy
The apprentice has now surpassed the master in that respect.Gwlad wrote:Cyril wrote:Luckily Dan Biggar would never scream in a ref's face and jump up and down like a kid having a tantrum, eh? Model proGwlad wrote:England's clear and unsportsmanlike targeting of Sexton was just another sign of a poor weekend for the integrity of Rugby Union. What with the blatant cheating by the French, biting and treatment of Sexton it reminds me that this is a sport where some think ti is okay to use fake blood.
Yeah he modeled himself on Farrell.
Farrell's fine now. I thought Biggar had grown up too, but it appears not. Perhaps he's just frustrated with the current Welsh set-up as I don't think he's like that too much for Ospreys these days.
Cyril- Posts : 7162
Join date : 2012-11-16
Re: Lions crash test dummy
BamBam wrote:Its unsurprising that Biggar would aspire to be like Owen Farrell, given the latter's quality
Except that Biggar is first choice 10 and Farrell can't hold that shirt down.
Gwlad- Posts : 4224
Join date : 2014-12-04
Re: Lions crash test dummy
Yeah, but Sarries are better than Wales...Gwlad wrote:BamBam wrote:Its unsurprising that Biggar would aspire to be like Owen Farrell, given the latter's quality
Except that Biggar is first choice 10 and Farrell can't hold that shirt down.
Cyril- Posts : 7162
Join date : 2012-11-16
Re: Lions crash test dummy
Can we please only use the report feature if it's actually report worthy?
The above post has been reported. If this post offends anyone then seriously turn off the internet.
The above post has been reported. If this post offends anyone then seriously turn off the internet.
Hero- Founder
- Posts : 28291
Join date : 2012-03-02
Age : 47
Location : Work toilet
Re: Lions crash test dummy
TJ wrote:I think Sexton would cope better than Farrell with being targeted because of his temperament and because he can move the ball on quicker
Wasn't that much wrong with Farrell's temperament after the late hit from Moriarty earlier in the tournament.
I'd go with Sexton and Ford as my 10s and Farrell and Henshaw as my 12s, with 2/3 other centre options (probably Joseph and Jones, possibly Ringrose as well, or cover from Daly and Payne selected in the back 3) on the plane.
I'd go with Sexton, Farrell and Joseph if I had to pick my test team now. I think two play-makers is the way to go, I'm just struggling to find a second option for second 5/8th.
In absence of an obvious candidate, I'd say that Henshaw is probably the best player and although he doesn't really fit the play maker game plan he could slot right in next to Sexton without much trouble if Farrell was injured.
Similar topics
» Lions 1st Test
» 2nd TEST - AUS vs BRITISH & IRISH LIONS - 29th June - (KO-11:05 GMT)
» LIONS STARTING TEST 13
» My Lions Team (3rd Test)
» Lions first test backline.
» 2nd TEST - AUS vs BRITISH & IRISH LIONS - 29th June - (KO-11:05 GMT)
» LIONS STARTING TEST 13
» My Lions Team (3rd Test)
» Lions first test backline.
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: International
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|