The v2 Forum
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

5 posters

Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Sat Mar 03, 2018 5:48 am

I have devised a very simple forecast model to take into account the remaining fixture lists of the bottom ten Premiership teams, as of "week 28" of the season, to come up with a prediction of their final positions & the three teams to be relegated.   I will aim to update this every week until it becomes clearer which teams will be relegated. The model assumes all teams "do reasonably well / perform as expected" in their remaining fixtures.   It is based on home & away performance against three classes of team: Class 1 = Man City; Class 2 = Man Utd, Liverpool, Spurs, Chelsea, Arsenal; Class 3 = the rest.

End of Week 37
All results for lower half teams were as expected except for:
Brighton 1 Man Utd 0
Stoke 1 Crystal Palace 2
Leicester 0 West Ham 2
WBA 1 Spurs 0
Man City 0 Huddersfield 0
Stoke are relegated and Brighton, West Ham and Crystal Palace have guaranteed safety.

One – Two Match Forecast Comment
Relegated: Stoke
Certainties to be Relegated: WBA
Favourite to be Relegated: Southampton
Still In Danger of Relegation: Huddersfield, Swansea
• All other teams ARE safe.
• Currently 38 points guarantees safety from relegation.
One - Two matches to go = 3 – 6 points to play for.

Rescheduled Matches from “Week’s 31 & 35”: 8th to 10th May
Swansea vs Southampton
Chelsea vs Huddersfield
Leicester vs Arsenal
Man City vs Brighton
Spurs vs Newcastle
West Ham vs Man Utd

Notes:
1) The most significant match is Swansea vs Southampton:
a) If either Swansea or Southampton win then WBA are relegated.
b) If Swansea win then Southampton become certainties for relegation.
c) If either Swansea or Southampton win then Huddersfield can secure safety by drawing at Chelsea.
2) If Huddersfield win they will secure safety.

Current Table
Position Football Team Played GD Points
---------- ------------------ -------- ------ --------
10 Newcastle 36 -10 41
11 Crystal Palace 37 -12 41
12 Bournemouth 37 -17 41
13 Watford 37 -19 41
14 Brighton 36 -14 40
15 West Ham 36 -22 38
16 Huddersfield 36 -29 36
17 Southampton 36 -19 33
18 Swansea 36 -26 33
19 WBA 37 -23 31
20 Stoke 37 -34 30

Predicted Final Table (One to Two Match Forecast)
Position Football Team Played GD Points
---------- ------------------ -------- ------ --------
10 Crystal Palace 38 -12 43
11 Newcastle 38 -13 41-42
12 Bournemouth 38 -18 41-42
13 Watford 38 -21 41
14 West Ham 38 -22 40-41
15 Brighton 38 -18 40
16 Swansea 38 -25 37
17 Huddersfield 38 -32 36-37
18 Southampton 38 -21 33-34
19 WBA 38 -24 31-32
20 Stoke 38 -35 30-31


Last edited by No name Bertie on Sun May 06, 2018 6:06 pm; edited 33 times in total
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Sat Mar 03, 2018 5:14 pm

March 03 2018 17:10.

No major surprises so far, except Everton have to now be explicitly considered as they fall into the bottom half of the table. Still all things being equal, they are not in danger of relegation.

A "good" result for WBA would have been an away draw, but they lose at Watford. 6 losses in a row in all competitions, their morale must be very low, yet they have some home matches coming up that they need to try to win. At some point they might "give up" which will mean a great opportunity for those that play them. By all accounts they put up a fight at Watford, but ultimately a lack of quality or confidence in front of goal cost them.
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by Dolphin Ziggler Sun Mar 04, 2018 3:19 pm

I think this counts as a "good result" by the parameters here.

Although what youve done is explain in a very long-winded way what a predictor is used for.

Dolphin Ziggler
Dolphin
Dolphin

Posts : 24108
Join date : 2012-03-01
Age : 35
Location : Making the Kessel Run

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Tue Mar 06, 2018 2:27 pm

Hi, if by "predictor" you mean the sort of thing that can be found on the BBC website where individuals fill in their predictions, then that is not a "model".  Models are automated and based on "parameterisations".  I am not saying my model is any good - just a reasonable starting point.

Brighton's result counts as a "better than expected (excellent) result" and the type of result that can break the "model forecast".  

The "forecast" for Southampton is currently relegation because Southampton have of their remaining 9 fixtures, 6 away matches, while two of their home matches are against Manchester City and Chelsea.  Basically Southampton have to win a few away matches to break the "forecast" of relegation.
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Wed Mar 07, 2018 8:27 pm

End of Week 28
Ten Match Forecast Comment
Highly Likely to be Relegated: WBA
Favourites to be Relegated: Stoke & Southampton
In Danger of Relegation: Crystal Palace, Swansea, Newcastle, Brighton
Other teams have breathing space, and all things being equal, should be safe.
Ten matches to go = thirty points to play for.

Current Table
PositionFootball TeamPlayedGDPoints
--------------------------------------------------
10Watford28-933
11Bournemouth28-1032
12Brighton28-1131
13West Ham28-1530
14Huddersfield28-2330
15Newcastle28-1129
16Southampton28-1227
17Crystal Palace28-1827
18Swansea28-2027
19Stoke28-2626
20WBA28-2020

Predicted Final Table (Ten Match Forecast)
PositionFootball TeamPlayedGDPoints
--------------------------------------------------
10Watford38-1543 - 44
11Bournemouth38-1441
12West Ham38-2039 - 40
13Huddersfield38-2939 - 40
14Brighton38-1738
15Newcastle38-1637 - 38
16Swansea38-2437
17Crystal Palace38-2236
18Southampton38-1734
19Stoke38-3234
20WBA38-2429
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Sat Mar 10, 2018 5:06 pm

Very bad results (for my model forecast) - WBA eventually hammered at home against Leicester 1 - 4, and West Ham beaten heavily at home against Burnley 0 - 3.

That's three premiership losses in a row for West Ham, away to Liverpool (4-1), away to Swansea (4-1) and at home to Burnley (0-3). Though the loss at Liverpool was to be expected, they were heavily defeated away to relegation rival Swansea and eventually heavily beaten at home to Burnley. West Ham next two games are home games against Manchester United and Southampton. Obviously their home game against Southampton is going to be very important.
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by Guest Sat Mar 10, 2018 5:20 pm

No name Bertie wrote:Very bad results (for my model forecast)

Laugh

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Thu Mar 15, 2018 11:34 pm

End of Week 29
Best result of the week: Brighton 2 Arsenal 1
All other results were more or less as expected.

Nine Match Forecast Comment
Certainties to be Relegated:  WBA
Favourites to be Relegated: Southampton & Stoke
In Danger of Relegation: Crystal Palace, Newcastle, Swansea , West Ham, Huddersfield
Other teams have breathing space, and all things being equal, should be safe.
Nine matches to go = 27 points to play for.

Current Table
PositionFootball TeamPlayedGDPoints
--------------------------------------------------
10Brighton29-1034
11Everton29-1634
12Bournemouth29-1033
13Swansea29-1730
14West Ham29-1830
15Huddersfield29-2530
16Newcastle29-1329
17Southampton29-1228
18Crystal Palace29-1927
19Stoke29-2627
20WBA29-2120

Predicted Final Table (Nine Match Forecast)
PositionFootball TeamPlayedGDPoints
--------------------------------------------------
10Everton38-1842-43
11Bournemouth38-1341-42
12Brighton38-1640-41
13Huddersfield38-2939-40
14West Ham38-2239
15Swansea38-2238
16Newcastle38-1637-38
17Crystal Palace38-2235-36
18Stoke38-3134-35
19Southampton38-1833
20WBA38-2428-29
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Sat Mar 17, 2018 3:43 pm

Halftime.

Stoke vs Everton 0 - 0: Stoke have a player sent off in a game they really have to be winning.  My model assumes a home win or a draw.

Huddersfield vs Crystal Palace 0 - 1: my model doesn't take into account that Roy Hodgson is a highly experienced manager used to digging teams out of difficulty or that Palace have some great players.  It just assumes that this is going to be either a home win or a draw. But in reality Palace were completely dominant in terms of control and attack in the first half. Chalk and cheese. Wagner somehow has to pull this around (unlikely).
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Sat Mar 17, 2018 5:07 pm

Week 31 Final Results
Stoke vs Everton 1 - 2: I have to say that Paul Lambert was unlucky in having one of his players sent off and being reduced to ten men in the 30th minute of the first half.  Stoke had been dominant up to that point.  And then Paul Lambert was unlucky again in the second half.  He added substitute Choupo-Moting in the 72nd minute, who scored an equaliser for Stoke five minutes later but in the process injured himself and so had to be substituted in the 79th minute.  Everton then score the winner in the 84th minute.

Huddersfield 0 Crystal Palace 2:  Palace were convincing winners.  A very bad result for Huddersfield mitigated by the fact that Stoke also had a very bad result.

Bournemouth 2 WBA 1: a very good early performance by Pardew's team in the first half to go one - up. But Bournemouth came roaring back in the second half to expose WBA's lack of quality and come away with a home win.
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by Dolphin Ziggler Sat Mar 17, 2018 7:25 pm

No name Bertie wrote:
Huddersfield vs Crystal Palace 0 - 1: my model doesn't take into account that Roy Hodgson is a highly experienced manager used to digging teams out of difficulty or that Palace have some great players.

Nore?

Dolphin Ziggler
Dolphin
Dolphin

Posts : 24108
Join date : 2012-03-01
Age : 35
Location : Making the Kessel Run

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Fri Mar 30, 2018 4:15 am

End of Week 30
All results more or less as expected EXCEPT FOR:
WBA 1 Leicester 4
West Ham 0 Burnley 3
Which represent very poor results for WBA and West Ham
• My simple model doesn’t account for momentum and at the moment West Ham have poor momentum losing their past three premiership matches 4-1, 4-1 and 0-3. Furthermore the atmosphere at West Ham’s home ground has turned extremely sour and with five home matches in their remaining fixtures it is imperative West Ham perform well at home to avoid relegation.
• I could comment on WBA but there is no point as they are as good as relegated as it stands.

Eight Match Forecast Comment
Certainties to be Relegated: WBA
Favourites to be Relegated: Southampton & Stoke
In Danger of Relegation: Crystal Palace, West Ham, Huddersfield, Newcastle, Swansea.
• Note that there is a closing of the gap between Stoke (currently a favourite for relegation) and the teams in danger of relegation. What with things that my model doesn’t take into account such as momentum and the change of manager at Southampton, things could begin to switch around over the coming rounds of matches.
• Other teams have breathing space, and all things being equal, should be safe.
Eight matches to go = 24 points to play for.

Current Table
PositionFootball TeamPlayedGDPoints
--------------------------------------------------
10Everton30-1136
11Brighton30-1234
12Bournemouth30-1333
13Newcastle30-1032
14Swansea30-1731
15Huddersfield30-2531
16West Ham30-2130
17Southampton30-1528
18Crystal Palace30-2027
19Stoke30-2827
20WBA30-2420

Predicted Final Table (Eight Match Forecast)
PositionFootball TeamPlayedGDPoints
--------------------------------------------------
10Everton38-1743-44
11Bournemouth38-1641
12Brighton38-1740
13Newcastle38-1438-39
14Swansea38-2138-39
15Huddersfield38-2938-39
16West Ham38-2637
17Crystal Palace38-2135-36
18Stoke38-3234-35
19Southampton38-2032-33
20WBA38-2826-27
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Sat Mar 31, 2018 6:06 am

I just want to note that the West Ham vs Southampton match today is critical.  

If Southampton win at West Ham there will be a near six point swing in my model prediction and for the first time there will be a new favourite for relegation - West Ham rather than Southampton.  [My model turns this match from a so-called six-pointer into a "potential five four and a half-pointer" and no I am not going to try to explain that.]

I know that my model is a bit simple (rubbish some might say) but it does help to provide a yardstick in how the present may affect the future.


Last edited by No name Bertie on Sat Mar 31, 2018 8:05 pm; edited 1 time in total
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by Dolphin Ziggler Sat Mar 31, 2018 1:33 pm

It’s my favourite part of this website

Dolphin Ziggler
Dolphin
Dolphin

Posts : 24108
Join date : 2012-03-01
Age : 35
Location : Making the Kessel Run

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Sat Mar 31, 2018 8:16 pm

The relegation scrap is beginning to resolve itself.  Very bad result for Brighton, but Brighton has breathing space to absorb that home loss.  WBA continue to disappoint (another home loss).  WBA have 6 games remaining and probably need to win all of them to survive (having only won three so far): my model forecasts safety to be at around 37 to 38 points.
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by Lowlandbrit Sun Apr 01, 2018 7:37 am

I'm finding it hard to look past the three teams with the worst goal difference (Stoke, Huddersfield, WBA) at the moment.

Lowlandbrit

Posts : 2641
Join date : 2011-06-15
Location : Netherlands

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Fri Apr 06, 2018 3:57 am

End of Week 31
Only four matches played. The remaining six have yet to be rescheduled. Hence “week 31” of the premiership is incomplete.
All results were as expected except for:
Stoke 1 Everton 2
Huddersfield 0 Crystal Palace 2
Very poor results for Stoke & Huddersfield, excellent result for Crystal Palace.

Seven - Eight Match Forecast Comment
Certainties to be Relegated: WBA
Favourites to be Relegated: Stoke & Southampton
In Danger of Relegation: Huddersfield, West Ham.
• Other teams have breathing space, and all things being equal, should be safe.
Seven - Eight matches to go = 21 – 24 points to play for

Current Table
PositionFootball TeamPlayedGDPoints
--------------------------------------------------
10Bournemouth31-1236
11Watford31-1636
12Brighton30-1234
13Newcastle30-1032
14Swansea30-1731
15Huddersfield31-2731
16Crystal Palace31-1830
17West Ham30-2130
18Southampton30-1528
19Stoke31-2927
20WBA31-2520

Predicted Final Table (Seven - Eight Match Forecast)
PositionFootball TeamPlayedGDPoints
--------------------------------------------------
10Watford38-1944-45
11Bournemouth38-1542
12Brighton38-1740
13Newcastle38-1438-39
14Swansea38-2138-39
15Crystal Palace38-1938
16West Ham38-2637
17Huddersfield38-3236-37
18Southampton38-2032-33
19Stoke38-3432-33
20WBA38-2826
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Fri Apr 06, 2018 5:07 am

Lowlandbrit wrote:I'm finding it hard to look past the three teams with the worst goal difference (Stoke, Huddersfield, WBA) at the moment.
Hi, it is entirely possible that WBA, Stoke and Huddersfield could be relegated. But as it stands and given the remaining fixtures, Southampton have to start to pull off some notable away wins or have a win or two against a top six side, while Huddersfield have to perform somewhat poorly at home (they have two important home matches against Watford and Everton).
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by Dolphin Ziggler Fri Apr 06, 2018 12:24 pm

You're very behind!

Dolphin Ziggler
Dolphin
Dolphin

Posts : 24108
Join date : 2012-03-01
Age : 35
Location : Making the Kessel Run

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Sat Apr 07, 2018 7:20 pm

No home wins, Newcastle and Burnley come away with away wins. Newcastle are now more or less safe from relegation.
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Sun Apr 08, 2018 10:55 pm

End of Week 32
All results for lower half teams were as expected except for:
Brighton 0 Leicester 2
WBA 1 Burnley 2
These represent poorer than expected results for WBA and Brighton (according to the model).

Six - Seven Match Forecast Comment
Certainties to be Relegated: WBA
Favourites to be Relegated: Southampton & Stoke
In Danger of Relegation: Huddersfield, Crystal Palace
• Other teams have breathing space, and all things being equal, should be safe.
Note: Six - Seven matches to go = 18 – 21 points to play for. “Week 31” round of matches incomplete

Current Table
PositionFootball TeamPlayedGDPoints
--------------------------------------------------
10Bournemouth32-1237
11Watford32-1637
12Newcastle31-935
13Brighton31-1434
14West Ham31-1833
15Swansea31-1931
16Huddersfield32-2831
17Crystal Palace32-1930
18Southampton31-1828
19Stoke32-3227
20WBA32-2620

Predicted Final Table (Six to Seven Match Forecast)
PositionFootball TeamPlayedGDPoints
--------------------------------------------------
10Watford38-1943-44
11Bournemouth38-1542-43
12Newcastle38-1339-40
13Swansea38-2138-39
14Brighton38-2038
15West Ham38-2338
16Crystal Palace38-1937-38
17Huddersfield38-3236
18Stoke38-3532-33
19Southampton38-2332
20WBA38-3024
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by Beer Mon Apr 09, 2018 9:49 am

You're still a week behind. Newcastle are 10th on 38 points.

Beer

Posts : 14734
Join date : 2011-06-21
Age : 38
Location : 'Whose kids are these? And how'd they get in my Lincoln?'

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by Guest Mon Apr 09, 2018 4:12 pm

Beer wrote:You're still a week behind. Newcastle are 10th on 38 points.

Not bad for a championship squad

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Mon Apr 09, 2018 11:10 pm

End of Week 33
All results for lower half teams were as expected except for:
Leicester 1 Newcastle 2
Watford 1 Burnley 2
Chelsea 1 West Ham 1
Newcastle, Burnley and West Ham performed much better than expected (according to the model). Newcastle are now effectively safe from relegation with three wins in a row. An oddity in this round of results was the fact that apart from Arsenal there were no home wins. Brighton slip into the “danger zone” after a home draw and following a home loss from last week. According to the model Brighton have no remaining winnable games but they do have games for which they can pick up a point (draw).

Five - Six Match Forecast Comment
Certainties to be Relegated: WBA
Favourites to be Relegated: Stoke & Southampton
In Danger of Relegation: Huddersfield, Brighton
• Other teams have breathing space, and all things being equal, should be safe.
Five - Six matches to go = 15 – 18 points to play for.
Note: “Week 31” round of matches are incomplete: one match has been rescheduled for 19th April and the rest for 8-10th May.

Week 34 Fixtures: 14th to 16th April
Southampton vs Chelsea
Burnley vs Leicester City
Crystal Palace vs Brighton
Huddersfield vs Watford
Swansea City vs Everton
Liverpool vs Bournemouth
Tottenham vs Man City
Newcastle vs Arsenal
Man United vs WBA
West Ham vs Stoke
Note: Week 35 round of matches begin just a day later from 17th April onwards.

Current Table
Position Football Team Played GD Points
---------- ----------------------------------------
10 Newcastle32-838
11 Bournemouth33-1238
12 Watford33-1737
13 Brighton32-1435
14 West Ham32-1834
15 Swansea32-1932
16 Huddersfield33-2832
17 Crystal Palace33-1931
18 Southampton32-1928
19 Stoke33-3327
20 WBA33-2621

Predicted Final Table (Five to Six Match Forecast)
Position Football Team Played GD Points
---------- ----------------------------------------
10 Newcastle38-1242
11 Bournemouth38-1541-42
12 Watford38-2141-42
13 Swansea38-2139
14 West Ham38-2139
15 Crystal Palace38-1938
16 Brighton38-2037
17 Huddersfield38-3236-37
18 Southampton38-2232
19 Stoke38-3532
20 WBA38-3023
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by Dolphin Ziggler Mon Apr 09, 2018 11:34 pm

No name Bertie wrote: They do have games for which they can pick up a point (draw)

Your system has absolutely cracked this analysis business.

Dolphin Ziggler
Dolphin
Dolphin

Posts : 24108
Join date : 2012-03-01
Age : 35
Location : Making the Kessel Run

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Sat Apr 14, 2018 1:46 pm

If Southampton hold on for a home win against Chelsea AND Huddersfield lose at home to Watford, then we will have a new favourite for relegation - Huddersfield.
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by Guest Sat Apr 14, 2018 2:12 pm

No name Bertie wrote:If Southampton hold on for a home win against Chelsea

Southampton 2-3 Chelsea - Giroud (2), Hazard

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Sat Apr 14, 2018 5:15 pm

So in the end  the results were more or less as expected with Southampton losing and Huddersfield winning.  

However Southampton were leading 2-0 heading into the 70th minute while there has been some doubt with regard the attitude of the Chelsea players with Conte likely leaving in the summer - but somehow they scored three goals in 8 minutes resulting in a home loss for Southampton but against a top six side.  

With Huddersfield there has been some doubt regarding their ability to score (less than one goal a game) but they managed to score in the 91st minute for a home win after withstanding attacking pressure from Watford in the earlier part of the game.
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Sat Apr 14, 2018 5:20 pm

Arsenal have not done very well away and given they had a tough game in Russia on Thursday evening, there must be a very good chance for Newcastle to get a win over them at home on Sunday just after midday (depending on Benitez's tactics) - as most Arsenal players will have at most one day of rest and one day of light training (assuming Wenger plays his strongest side). However the "expected result" for Newcastle vs Arsenal is either a home loss or a home draw.
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Tue Apr 17, 2018 3:10 am

End of Week 34
All results for lower half teams were as expected except for:
Man Utd 0 WBA 1
Newcastle 2 Arsenal 1
With WBA and Newcastle performing much better than expected (according to the model). It is likely Arsenal suffered the effects of playing in Russia 2½ days previously and the effects of travelling back from Russia & up to Newcastle.

Four - Five Match Forecast Comment
Certainties to be Relegated: WBA
Favourites to be Relegated: Southampton & Stoke
In Danger of Relegation: Brighton, Huddersfield.
• Other teams have breathing space, and all things being equal, should be safe.
Four - Five matches to go = 12 – 15 points to play for.
Note: “Week 31” round of matches are incomplete: one match has been rescheduled for 19th April and the rest for 8-10th May.

”Week 35 Fixtures” 17th to 23rd April
One “week 35” fixture is postponed due to the FA Cup.
One “week 31” fixture is rescheduled in this period.
Note Burnley play twice and Huddersfield don’t play at all in this period.

Brighton vs Spurs
Bournemouth vs Man Utd
Burnley vs Chelsea [reschedule Week 31 Fixture]
Leicester vs Southampton
WBA vs Liverpool
Watford vs Crystal Palace
Arsenal vs West Ham
Stoke vs Burnley
Man City vs Swansea
Everton vs Newcastle

Current Table
Position Football Team Played GD Points
---------- ------------------ -------- ------ --------
10 Newcastle 33 -7 41
11 Bournemouth 34 -15 38
12 Watford 34 -18 37
13 Brighton 33 -15 35
14 West Ham 33 -18 35
15 Huddersfield 34 -27 35
16 Crystal Palace 34 -18 34
17 Swansea 33 -19 33
18 Southampton 33 -20 28
19 Stoke 34 -33 28
20 WBA 34 -25 24

Predicted Final Table (Four to Five Match Forecast)
Position Football Team Played GD Points
---------- ------------------ -------- ------ --------
10 Newcastle 38 -10 44-45
11 Bournemouth 38 -16 41-42
12 Watford 38 -21 41
13 Crystal Palace 38 -18 39
14 Swansea 38 -21 38
15 West Ham 38 -22 38
16 Huddersfield 38 -31 37-38
17 Brighton 38 -21 36-37
18 Stoke 38 -35 32-33
19 Southampton 38 -22 31-32
20 WBA 38 -27 26
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Wed Apr 25, 2018 5:38 am

End of Week 35
All results for lower half teams were as expected.

Three - Four Match Forecast Comment
Certainties to be Relegated: WBA
Favourites to be Relegated: Stoke & Southampton  
In Danger of Relegation: Brighton.
• Other teams have breathing space, and all things being equal, should be safe.
• Currently 42 points guarantees safety from relegation.
Three - Four matches to go = 9 – 12 points to play for.
Note: “Week 31” & “Week 35” round of matches are incomplete: these have been rescheduled for 8-10th May.

”Week 36 Fixtures” 28th to 30th April
Liverpool vs Stoke
Burnley vs Brighton
Crystal Palace vs Leicester
Huddersfield vs Everton
Newcastle vs WBA
Southampton vs Bournemouth
Swansea vs Chelsea
West Ham vs Man City
Man United vs Arsenal
Spurs vs Watford

Note: WBA are expected to be relegated this week.  Anything other than a victory away to Newcastle will see them relegated.
WBA will also be relegated if Swansea beat Chelsea.  

It is also possible but unlikely for Stoke to be relegated this week.  However by the end of this week Stoke will likely fall into
the category of certainties to be relegated.

Current Table
PositionFootball TeamPlayedGDPoints
--------------------------------------------------
10Newcastle34-841
11Bournemouth35-1738
12Watford35-1838
13Brighton34-1536
14Crystal Palace35-1835
15West Ham34-2135
16Huddersfield34-2735
17Swansea34-2433
18Southampton34-2029
19Stoke35-3329
20WBA35-2525

Predicted Final Table (Three to Four Match Forecast)
PositionFootball TeamPlayedGDPoints
--------------------------------------------------
10Newcastle38-1144
11Bournemouth38-1841
12Watford38-2240
13Crystal Palace38-1839-40
14West Ham38-2338
15Swansea38-2438
16Huddersfield38-3137-38
17Brighton38-2037
18Southampton38-2232
19Stoke38-3531-32
20WBA38-2726-27
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Wed May 02, 2018 6:13 pm

End of Week 36
All results for lower half teams were as expected except for:
Liverpool 0 Stoke 0
Huddersfield 0 Everton 2
Newcastle 0 WBA 1
The most significant result was Huddersfield losing at home to Everton. This puts Huddersfield very much at risk of relegation

Two - Three Match Forecast Comment
Certainties to be Relegated: WBA
Favourites to be Relegated: Stoke & Southampton
Next likely to be Relegated: Huddersfield
In Danger of Relegation: Swansea, Brighton, West Ham
• Other teams are safe or more or less safe.
• Currently 40 points guarantees safety from relegation.
Two - Three matches to go = 6 – 9 points to play for.
Note: “Week 31” & “Week 35” round of matches are incomplete: these have been rescheduled for 8-10th May.

“Week 37 Fixtures” 4th to 6th May
Brighton vs Man United
Stoke vs Crystal Palace
Bournemouth vs Swansea
Leicester vs West Ham
Watford vs Newcastle
WBA vs Spurs
Everton vs Southampton
Man City vs Huddersfield
Arsenal vs Burnley
Chelsea vs Liverpool

Notes:
1) There are three four ways WBA could be relegated this week: a) they do not beat Spurs. b) Swansea win at Bournemouth. c) Southampton win at Everton. d) Stoke beat Crystal Palace (because Swansea are scheduled to play both Stoke & Southampton).
2) If Stoke lose they could be relegated this week if Swansea draw at Bournemouth or Southampton win at Everton will be relegated this week because Swansea play Southampton next week. Stoke could also be relegated this week if they draw depending on other results.
3) If Huddersfield lose at Man City and Southampton win at Everton, then Huddersfield will replace Southampton as favourite for relegation.

Current Table
PositionFootball TeamPlayedGDPoints
--------------------------------------------------
10Newcastle35-941
11Crystal Palace36-1338
12Bournemouth36-1838
13Watford36-2038
14Brighton35-1537
15West Ham35-2435
16Huddersfield35-2935
17Swansea35-2533
18Southampton35-1932
19Stoke36-3330
20WBA36-2428

Predicted Final Table (Two to Three Match Forecast)
PositionFootball TeamPlayedGDPoints
--------------------------------------------------
10Newcastle38-1242
11Crystal Palace38-1340-41
12Bournemouth38-1840-41
13Watford38-2240
14West Ham38-2538
15Brighton38-2037-38
16Swansea38-2537-38
17Huddersfield38-3435-36
18Southampton38-2133
19Stoke38-3332-33
20WBA38-2529


Last edited by No name Bertie on Sat May 05, 2018 1:36 pm; edited 8 times in total
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Wed May 02, 2018 6:30 pm

Update: This season WBA Premiership Performance
Tony Pulis: ...... Played 12: Points 10: Points/game = 0.83:  Goals scored/game = 0.75: Goals conceded/game = 1.50
Gary Megson: .. Played 02: Points 02: Points/game = 1.00:  Goals scored/game = 1.50: Goals conceded/game = 1.50
Alan Pardew: ... Played 18: Points 08: Points/game = 0.44:  Goals scored/game = 0.72: Goals conceded/game = 1.67
Darren Moore: . Played 04: Points 08: Points/game = 2.00:  Goals scored/game = 1.25: Goals conceded/game = 0.75

Update: This season Watford Premiership Performance
Marco Silva: .... Played 24: Points 26: Points/game = 1.08:  Goals scored/game = 1.38: Goals conceded/game = 1.83
Javi Gracia: ..... Played 12: Points 12: Points/game = 1.00:  Goals scored/game = 0.83: Goals conceded/game = 1.58
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Fri May 04, 2018 9:56 pm

Brighton perform above expectation by beating Man Utd at home. They gain three points taking them to 40 points which guarantees them safety from relegation.  Brighton's last two games are away to Manchester City and away to Liverpool.
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Sat May 05, 2018 2:30 pm

Stoke lose at home to Crystal Palace.  This means they are relegated because they now cannot catch Huddersfield, and they cannot catch both of Swansea and Southampton, because Swansea and Southampton play against each other next Tuesday, so at least one of them will finish above Stoke.

The reason for Stoke's relegation seems to be a lack of defensive energy and a lack of quality in attack; when they lose the ball not enough players are willing to track back - leaving the defence exposed.  Despite having a top goalkeeper in Jack Butland they have conceded 67 goals and only scored 34 goals.  The die was set under Mark Hughes management.
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Sun May 06, 2018 12:41 am

With the results to date (following Saturday May 5th), 38 points guarantees safety. So West Ham have avoided relegation with their win away at Leicester. Currently:
a) Stoke are relegated.
b) WBA are certainties to be relegated (but a heroic effort so far from Darren Moore).
c) One of Southampton, Huddersfield and Swansea will be relegated: Southampton are favorites to be relegated, followed by Huddersfield and then Swansea.
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Sun May 06, 2018 6:09 pm

End of Week 37
All results for lower half teams were as expected except for:
Brighton 1 Man Utd 0
Stoke 1 Crystal Palace 2
Leicester 0 West Ham 2
WBA 1 Spurs 0
Man City 0 Huddersfield 0
Stoke are relegated and Brighton, West Ham and Crystal Palace have guaranteed safety.  

One – Two Match Forecast Comment
Relegated: Stoke
Certainties to be Relegated: WBA
Favourite to be Relegated: Southampton
Still In Danger of Relegation: Huddersfield, Swansea
• All other teams ARE safe.
• Currently 38 points guarantees safety from relegation.
Note: One - Two matches to go = 3 – 6 points to play for.

Rescheduled Matches from “Week’s 31 & 35”: 8th to 10th May
Swansea vs Southampton
Chelsea vs Huddersfield
Leicester vs Arsenal
Man City vs Brighton
Spurs vs Newcastle
West Ham vs Man Utd

Notes:  
1) The most significant match is Swansea vs Southampton:
a) If either Swansea or Southampton win then WBA are relegated.  
b) If Swansea win then Southampton become certainties for relegation.
c) As pointed out by Dolphin Ziggler below, if Southampton win they become certainties to stay up (by means of goal difference over Swansea).
d) If either Swansea or Southampton win then Huddersfield can secure safety by drawing at Chelsea.
2) If Huddersfield win they will secure safety.

Current Table
Position Football Team Played GD Points
---------- ------------------ -------- ------ --------
10 Newcastle 36 -10 41
11 Crystal Palace 37 -12 41
12 Bournemouth 37 -17 41
13 Watford 37 -19 41
14 Brighton 36 -14 40
15 West Ham 36 -22 38
16 Huddersfield 36 -29 36
17 Southampton 36 -19 33
18 Swansea 36 -26 33
19 WBA 37 -23 31
20 Stoke 37 -34 30

Predicted Final Table (One to Two Match Forecast)
Position Football Team Played GD Points
---------- ------------------ -------- ------ --------
10 Crystal Palace 38 -12 43
11 Newcastle 38 -13 41-42
12 Bournemouth 38 -18 41-42
13 Watford 38 -21 41
14 West Ham 38 -22 40-41
15 Brighton 38 -18 40
16 Swansea 38 -25 37
17 Huddersfield 38 -32 36-37
18 Southampton 38 -21 33-34
19 WBA 38 -24 31-32
20 Stoke 38 -35 30-31


Last edited by No name Bertie on Sun May 06, 2018 9:24 pm; edited 1 time in total
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by Dolphin Ziggler Sun May 06, 2018 7:04 pm

All results went as expect except half.
Southampton are all but safe if they beat Swansea as there’d need at least a nine goal swing

Dolphin Ziggler
Dolphin
Dolphin

Posts : 24108
Join date : 2012-03-01
Age : 35
Location : Making the Kessel Run

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Wed May 09, 2018 10:42 pm

So WBA, Stoke and free-falling Swansea are relegated, while Southampton and Huddersfield survive with one game to play.

Overall the model was probably the simplest model possible to take into account the remaining fixtures to be played with ten rounds of games to go.

To improve the model, to make it slightly less simple, I have noticed a few factors that could be introduced to improve the model. The most important factor is "momentum" - when a team goes on either a "good run" or a "bad run". This was why the model failed to recognise the danger to Swansea until more or less the last moment.
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by Ent Wed May 09, 2018 10:50 pm

The last 2 month moment...

Who did the model predict relegation for initially?

Ent

Posts : 7337
Join date : 2011-05-02

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by No name Bertie Wed May 09, 2018 11:00 pm

My ten match forecast (30 points remaining) is given below. I had WBA, Stoke and Southampton as favourites. They remained favourites until this mid-week series of rescheduled games - when Swansea blew their chances, and Southampton and Huddersfield endeavoured to get the points to drag themselves to safety. Southampton are not "mathematically safe" but they are three points ahead of Swansea with a far superior goal difference.

End of Week 28
Ten Match Forecast Comment
Highly Likely to be Relegated: WBA
Favourites to be Relegated: Stoke & Southampton
In Danger of Relegation: Crystal Palace, Swansea, Newcastle, Brighton
Other teams have breathing space, and all things being equal, should be safe.
Ten matches to go = thirty points to play for.

Predicted Final Table (Ten Match Forecast)
PositionFootball TeamPlayedGDPoints
--------------------------------------------------
10Watford38-1543 - 44
11Bournemouth38-1441
12West Ham38-2039 - 40
13Huddersfield38-2939 - 40
14Brighton38-1738
15Newcastle38-1637 - 38
16Swansea38-2437
17Crystal Palace38-2236
18Southampton38-1734
19Stoke38-3234
20WBA38-2429
No name Bertie
No name Bertie

Posts : 3597
Join date : 2017-02-24

Back to top Go down

Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress Empty Re: Bertie's Relegation Prediction Thread - A Work in Progress

Post by Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum