The v2 Forum
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

England Vs India ODI series ratings

4 posters

Go down

England Vs India ODI series ratings Empty England Vs India ODI series ratings

Post by Guest Fri 28 Oct 2011, 4:55 pm

sorry guys i know they are late, but here are my series ratings, let me know what you think, and feel free to make your own.....

Alistair Cook-6 Two half centuries, but some poor captaincy
Craig Kieswetter-3-Poor with the bat,on and off with the gloves
Jonathon Trott-7, some good innings, but got plenty of starts and only went on once.
KP-7, started to show signs of form, again and was looking like himself again
Jonny Bairstow-5, only one decent innings apart from that, tough start for him
Ravi Bopara-4-only one decent knock, and his bowling was ineffective
Samit Patel-7-couple of knocks with the bat,and his bowling is coming along.
Graeme Swann-3, had an awful series with bat and ball
Steven Finn-9, Best player for england in the series, maturing as a bowler
Tim Bresnan-4-Poor by his standards
Jade Dernbach-4-poor
Scott Borthwick-3 only one game, but went at nearly 7 an over
Ian Bell-3-only one game but didnt impress
Stuart Meaker-7


India

Ajinkya Rahane-8- very promising batsman for india, but feel better suited to test match cricket
Parthiv Patel-5, poor
Gautam Gambhir-7 pretty good series for him.
Virat Kohli-9, another good series for him, a real find for india
M.S.Dhoni-8- didnt get out at all, all series, and some good keeping
Suresh Raina-7
Ravindra Jadeja-7- good with bat and ball
R.Ashwin-8
Praveen Kumar-6, poor by his standards
Vinay Kumar-8-very good bowling from him
Umesh Yadav-7, got better as series went on, until unforutnate injury
Varun AAron-8,
Manoj Tiwary-6

sorry if i have forgot anyone


Last edited by cricketfan90 on Fri 28 Oct 2011, 4:57 pm; edited 1 time in total

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

England Vs India ODI series ratings Empty Re: England Vs India ODI series ratings

Post by Mad for Chelsea Fri 28 Oct 2011, 4:56 pm

Meaker?

Mad for Chelsea

Posts : 12103
Join date : 2011-02-11
Age : 36

Back to top Go down

England Vs India ODI series ratings Empty Re: England Vs India ODI series ratings

Post by Guest Fri 28 Oct 2011, 5:36 pm

edited MFC, any one wanna comment on the votes?

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

England Vs India ODI series ratings Empty Re: England Vs India ODI series ratings

Post by Gregers Fri 28 Oct 2011, 5:40 pm

Alistair Cook - 5 Looked decent early on in the series but fell away. Captaincy not good enough for One Dau Cricket
Craig Kieswetter- 3 Dropped some sitters, missed run outs. Poor with the bat
Jonathon Trott- 5 Too slow once again from trott
KP - 6 Looked almost good in the 3rd ODI but this can go down as YET ANOTHER Series without a hundred. Needs a hundred in the next series or should be dropped
Jonny Bairstow - 3 Not ready for International cricket
Ravi Bopara - 2 What does he add exactly? Rubbish with the bat, did nothing with the ball
Samit Patel - 6 A few good innings, and actually did something with the ball!
Graeme Swann - 2 Wasn't himself, is the rift with KP that bad?
Steven Finn - 8 England's man of the series, not that he had any competition. Surely must be ready for tests now?
Tim Bresnan - 5 Looked tired but gave his all as usual
Jade Dernbach- 2 Not good enough. Whats the next ball? Oh its a slowie!
Scott Borthwick - Looked average, although when the rest of the attack struggles you cannot blame the young spinner!
Ian Bell - 3 Came in on a lose lose situation, should be playing over Trott
Stuart Meaker - 6 Lets not get too far ahead of ourselves but he looked decent. Bowled with pace and looked like he actually gave a damn


India

Ajinkya Rahane - 8 Very good once again, definitely a star of Indian cricket in the future
Parthiv Patel - 5 Didn't do that much. Keeping the space in the side warm for when Rohit is fit again?
Gautam Gambhir - 7 Mr Dependable. Gambhir showed why he is far better than Trott in this series
Virat Kohli - 9 Brilliant young batsman, tremendous talent and a joy to watch
M.S.Dhoni - 10 Awesome series from the skipper. Some inspired captaining decisions. Brilliant with the bat as always. And had a good series with the glove.
Suresh Raina - 7 Wasn't needed that much but when he was the little man was brilliant as always. Can anyone hit a ball better?
Ravindra Jadeja - 7 Great find for India down the order with the bat. And handy with the ball.
R.Ashwin - 8 The Ashwin or Harby argument still rages on but based on this series Ashwin is edging ahead. Was a million times the player swann was!
Praveen Kumar - 6 Quiet series from him but wasn't expensive. Even as a third bowler he was probably better than all of Englands bowlers except for the Finnster
Vinay Kumar - 8 Showed why the Indians rate him. Nigh on unplayable at times. Great series
Umesh Yadav - 8 India proving they are producing quality one day fast bowlers at the moment. A product of the IPL undoubtably. Got a lot of talent tho.
Varun Aaron - 7 Got his chance and took it well. As with Yadav their is serious competition for fast bowling places in this team
Manoj Tiwary - 6 Did what he had to do nicely.

Gregers

Posts : 15025
Join date : 2011-01-28
Age : 33
Location : Brighton, England

https://www.facebook.com/Gregers25

Back to top Go down

England Vs India ODI series ratings Empty Re: England Vs India ODI series ratings

Post by Guest Fri 28 Oct 2011, 5:42 pm

think you were a bit harsh on trott gregers. He did his job which is to bat through, its not his fault that are bowlers were awful in this series.

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

England Vs India ODI series ratings Empty Re: England Vs India ODI series ratings

Post by Demon Racer Fri 28 Oct 2011, 5:42 pm

Surely Dhoni should be 9/10, as the English couldn't dislodge him in 4 innings, and played match winning knocks in the 1st and 5th ODI?

Rahane would be a 6 at best, he gets starts but never gets a big hundred.

Demon Racer

Posts : 459
Join date : 2011-10-24

Back to top Go down

England Vs India ODI series ratings Empty Re: England Vs India ODI series ratings

Post by Gregers Fri 28 Oct 2011, 5:44 pm

Not really Harsh, as I've stated numerous times Trott should be no where near this side

Gregers

Posts : 15025
Join date : 2011-01-28
Age : 33
Location : Brighton, England

https://www.facebook.com/Gregers25

Back to top Go down

England Vs India ODI series ratings Empty Re: England Vs India ODI series ratings

Post by Mad for Chelsea Fri 28 Oct 2011, 5:52 pm

Cook - 5. couple of decent sixties, but should have gone on. Captaincy average.
Kieswetter - 4. started poorly but then hit some decent knocks, failed to kick on though. Keeping was poor.
Trott - 7. England's best batsman, but would've wanted more than one fifty to show for it.
KP - 7. Continued the promising signs from this summer, but every time got out when well set.
Bopara - 3. Back to bad Ravi after a fine summer series. One decent start, bowling ineffective, and not the best fielder.
Bairstow - 3. One start, nothing else. Too many daft shots in the middle of batting collapses. Not ready yet.
Patel - 6. Decent series, couple of good knocks, though not yet convinced by his bowling it showed signs of improvement. Not fit enough though, not by a long way. Awful in the field and looked knackered after facing 40-50 balls which doesn't help.
Bresnan - 4. Looked tired, tried hard and bowled the odd good spell, bu for England's senior pace bowler this wasn't good enough.
Swann - 3. A rare poor series, looked jaded, though still produced some quality moments with the ball. Dropped some catches, and the off-field controversies won't help either.
Dernbach - 1. Ineffective with the ball, and doesn't add anything with the bat or in the field.
Finn - 9. Best seamer on show from either side, bowled with pace and energy, got plenty of life out of dead-looking pitches. Single-handedly dragged England back into the third match. This tour was possibly the making of him.
Meaker - 5. Showed promise and plenty of heart, but probably not quite ready yet.

Bell and Borthwick only played one match each and didn't contribute anything.

Will do India later

Mad for Chelsea

Posts : 12103
Join date : 2011-02-11
Age : 36

Back to top Go down

England Vs India ODI series ratings Empty Re: England Vs India ODI series ratings

Post by Guest Fri 28 Oct 2011, 6:25 pm

bit harsh on Dernbach mate....i dont think he deserves to get 1, thats harsh..

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

England Vs India ODI series ratings Empty Re: England Vs India ODI series ratings

Post by Mad for Chelsea Fri 28 Oct 2011, 6:29 pm

he was rubbish though, wasn't a threat in his first spell, got tonked at the death, can't bat and not a great fielder. I rate him, but it was an awful series, and don't see how he rates higher.

Mad for Chelsea

Posts : 12103
Join date : 2011-02-11
Age : 36

Back to top Go down

England Vs India ODI series ratings Empty Re: England Vs India ODI series ratings

Post by Guest Fri 28 Oct 2011, 6:32 pm

he had a poor series yh, but IMO he was better than a 1 lol.

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

England Vs India ODI series ratings Empty Re: England Vs India ODI series ratings

Post by ShankyCricket Fri 28 Oct 2011, 7:48 pm

Cook 3
Kies 3
Trott 7
KP 7
Flopara 1
Bairstow 1
Patel 6
Bresnan 5
Swann 2
Finn 8
Jade 0
Meaker 4
Borthwick 2
Bell 0

Rahane 5
Parthiv 1
Gambhir 8
Virat 9
Raina 7
Dhoni 10
Jadeja 8
Ashwin 9
Praveen 5
Vinay 6
Yadav 6
Aaron 7
Tiwary 2

ShankyCricket

Posts : 4546
Join date : 2011-01-28
Age : 30

Back to top Go down

England Vs India ODI series ratings Empty Re: England Vs India ODI series ratings

Post by Guest Sat 29 Oct 2011, 12:57 pm

people are being very harsh on dernbach. He dosent dserver to be a 0-2 thats harsh

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

England Vs India ODI series ratings Empty Re: England Vs India ODI series ratings

Post by Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum