Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
+13
formerly known as Sam
jimbopip
Oakdene
Luckless Pedestrian
PhilBB
No 7&1/2
Pete330v2
Irish Londoner
geoff999rugby
Welshmushroom
mikey_dragon
RiscaGame
Old Man
17 posters
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: Club Rugby
Page 8 of 11
Page 8 of 11 • 1, 2, 3 ... 7, 8, 9, 10, 11
Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
First topic message reminder :
New name, bit of a rebrand…..but same old Dragons? Hopefully not!
Player movements:
Players In:
Bradley Roberts from Ireland Ulster
JJ Hanrahan from France Clermont
Rhodri Jones from Wales Ospreys
Sean Lonsdale from England Exeter Chiefs
Max Clark from England Bath
George Nott from England London Irish
Sio Tomkinson from New Zealand Highlanders
Angus O'Brien from Wales Scarlets
Lewis Jones from Wales Cardiff
Rob Evans from Wales Scarlets
Players Out:
Taylor Davies returned to Wales Scarlets
Dan Babos released
Mesake Doge released
Tom Griffiths released
Jordan Olowofela returned to England Leicester Tigers
Max Williams released
Josh Lewis to Wales Merthyr
Jonah Holmes to England Ealing Trailfinders
Dan Baker to Wales Aberavon
Owen Jenkins to Wales Wales Sevens
Will Talbot-Davies to England Coventry
Greg Bateman retired
Joe Maksymiw to France Agen
Evan Lloyd to Wales Ebbw Vale
Carrick McDonough to Wales Ebbw Vale
Adam Warren to Wales Llandovery
Harry Fry to England Hartpury University
Some decent signings there, on paper. And lots of players leaving who were not that good. But also losing a couple of decent ones in Doge and Holmes.
Fingers crossed for a few more wins this season
New name, bit of a rebrand…..but same old Dragons? Hopefully not!
Player movements:
Players In:
Bradley Roberts from Ireland Ulster
JJ Hanrahan from France Clermont
Rhodri Jones from Wales Ospreys
Sean Lonsdale from England Exeter Chiefs
Max Clark from England Bath
George Nott from England London Irish
Sio Tomkinson from New Zealand Highlanders
Angus O'Brien from Wales Scarlets
Lewis Jones from Wales Cardiff
Rob Evans from Wales Scarlets
Players Out:
Taylor Davies returned to Wales Scarlets
Dan Babos released
Mesake Doge released
Tom Griffiths released
Jordan Olowofela returned to England Leicester Tigers
Max Williams released
Josh Lewis to Wales Merthyr
Jonah Holmes to England Ealing Trailfinders
Dan Baker to Wales Aberavon
Owen Jenkins to Wales Wales Sevens
Will Talbot-Davies to England Coventry
Greg Bateman retired
Joe Maksymiw to France Agen
Evan Lloyd to Wales Ebbw Vale
Carrick McDonough to Wales Ebbw Vale
Adam Warren to Wales Llandovery
Harry Fry to England Hartpury University
Some decent signings there, on paper. And lots of players leaving who were not that good. But also losing a couple of decent ones in Doge and Holmes.
Fingers crossed for a few more wins this season
Guest- Guest
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Buttress gone as chairman too. But still on the board and part owner. He was a good one. Local guy and passionate about rugby in the area (trying not to say the ‘R’ word as it gets people acting crazy!). He made good on his promise to get the Dragons back into private ownership. Can’t have been easy. I liked him and thought he was good for us. Will be missed.
Will be interesting to see what the new CEO and chairman bring to the club.
Will be interesting to see what the new CEO and chairman bring to the club.
TAFKA The Oracle- Posts : 576
Join date : 2023-02-11
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Can't fault him, now we are back in private ownership. I was sceptical at times, as to whether he would do it.
Did feel like he was taking a lot on, with his new stuff too. So something had to give.
Did feel like he was taking a lot on, with his new stuff too. So something had to give.
RiscaGame- Moderator
- Posts : 5926
Join date : 2016-01-24
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Dai will probably just sign 4 players like he talked about, we know two already as I have no doubt Hollis is impressive in training. I guess Funaki is more of a replacement for Moriarty though, with Griffiths always injured and unable to plug that gap. All the other signings need to be decent front 5 players, and apparently Lions are looking to offload 3 of their prop forwards. Not much faith in Dai’s recruitment though.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Just hope what happended to Sio doesn't happen with him. Comes with a good reputation, starts well..........but then fades to nothing due to poor coaching/poor structures/constant losses/lack of talent around him/homesickness/weather...... or one of the many other variables that must affect a player coming to Wales and the perennial worst team.
God, I'm depressing myself just reading that back!
God, I'm depressing myself just reading that back!
TAFKA The Oracle- Posts : 576
Join date : 2023-02-11
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
The two incoming centre's don't seem to be struggling with injury, I believe Sio had struggled prior to joining but he had good pedigree. Wilson has a similar pedigree. It doesn't really matter who is at back-row and in the backs if we're still relying on people like Coleman and Davies - I am still unconvinced of Dai being aware of this.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Filo Tiatia then!
Luckless Pedestrian- Posts : 24892
Join date : 2011-02-01
Age : 45
Location : Newport
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Was rumoured previously, good to actually have a defence coach as it's a step up on not having one. I'm still not entirely sold on what Dai is doing, it depends who is coming in next.
Incoming: Hollis (now as opposed to next season), Wilson, Funaki, Cummins, Lewis-Hughes. It was also rumoured that we would be having another one of Dai's mates, Wyn Jones, I have mixed feelings on that one.
I'm sure we have a few leaving but not sure who.
Incoming: Hollis (now as opposed to next season), Wilson, Funaki, Cummins, Lewis-Hughes. It was also rumoured that we would be having another one of Dai's mates, Wyn Jones, I have mixed feelings on that one.
I'm sure we have a few leaving but not sure who.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
So the rumour was true then.
I think this guy could be decent for us. He fully immersed himself at the Os and had a talismanic effect. I do think he could do similar for us, as players will buy into him, in my opinion.
I think this guy could be decent for us. He fully immersed himself at the Os and had a talismanic effect. I do think he could do similar for us, as players will buy into him, in my opinion.
RiscaGame- Moderator
- Posts : 5926
Join date : 2016-01-24
TAFKA The Oracle likes this post
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Ed Byrne to Cardiff from Leinster. Good player, not sure if he’s been struggling with injury though - hence we haven’t seen much of him. They’ll sign Ruddock next I bet.
* I posted this on the wrong thread.
* I posted this on the wrong thread.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
RiscaGame wrote:So the rumour was true then.
I think this guy could be decent for us. He fully immersed himself at the Os and had a talismanic effect. I do think he could do similar for us, as players will buy into him, in my opinion.
You wouldn't not buy into him, would you, he's pretty formidable!
My only slight concern is that he hasn't been a dedicated defence coach anywhere, as far as I can see, but I'm reliably informed that's not necessarily a problem...
Luckless Pedestrian- Posts : 24892
Join date : 2011-02-01
Age : 45
Location : Newport
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
I think it’s great that Filo is coming here, but then my dour pessimistic Welsh traits kick in and I just assume he’s getting some experience on the way to better things. Still, if so then great that he’s with us for some time if he can live up to expectations. On paper it looks an awesome appointment (although with no defence coach currently, any appointment looks good )
TAFKA The Oracle- Posts : 576
Join date : 2023-02-11
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Gonzalo Bertranou, Lewis Jones, Aki Seiuli, Sean Lonsdale, Sio Tomkinson, Max Clark, Corey Baldwin and Nathan Evans are leaving at the end of the season. I suspect Lydiate will retire, perhaps Leon Brown will too. Roberts could be off elsewhere, potentially back to SA after being snubbed. Worryingly that Griffiths, Coleman and Davies aren't mentioned.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
What's the deal with Brown's injury? He was a regular around the Wales squad and should be in his prime years.
Lonsdale I presume is off because there's been no international recognition coming his way, ditto Max Clark.
Corey Baldwin is an odd one, some hype out of age grade then failed to kick on at Chiefs, Scarlets and now Dragons.
Lonsdale I presume is off because there's been no international recognition coming his way, ditto Max Clark.
Corey Baldwin is an odd one, some hype out of age grade then failed to kick on at Chiefs, Scarlets and now Dragons.
formerly known as Sam- Posts : 21148
Join date : 2011-07-13
Age : 37
Location : Leicestershire
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
formerly known as Sam wrote:What's the deal with Brown's injury? He was a regular around the Wales squad and should be in his prime years.
Lonsdale I presume is off because there's been no international recognition coming his way, ditto Max Clark.
Corey Baldwin is an odd one, some hype out of age grade then failed to kick on at Chiefs, Scarlets and now Dragons.
Brown is just always injured, had he not been he could be a very good player by now. We need him to go really.
Lonsdale is someone I would have liked us to keep, given he can play across the back-row. Clark was somewhat snubbed by Dai as was Sio to an extent, the former could have done more but his opportunities were also limited - I rate both as having a higher ceiling that Steff Hughes. Clark will probably stay with Cardiff.
Baldwin is meh.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Just seen this graphic of all the Scarlets players leaving. Which of these do you reckon will end up at the Dragons? It’s inevitable we’ll get a few. Probably way past their sell by date and will do very little to nothing for us!
I’ve said it before, but if they’re not good enough for the Scarlets any more then they shouldn’t be good enough for us. Rarely, very rarely, you might get a very good player who has fallen out of favour and they might be looking to jump ship. But usually these players are not offered new contracts because they’re over the hill or have completely gone off the boil and they never seem to regain any form when they join us.
So would you have any of these at the Dragons for next season?
P.s. obviously some have signed for other teams so we can’t sign them ourselves. But some will be available and perhaps looking for one last hurrah.
I’ve said it before, but if they’re not good enough for the Scarlets any more then they shouldn’t be good enough for us. Rarely, very rarely, you might get a very good player who has fallen out of favour and they might be looking to jump ship. But usually these players are not offered new contracts because they’re over the hill or have completely gone off the boil and they never seem to regain any form when they join us.
So would you have any of these at the Dragons for next season?
P.s. obviously some have signed for other teams so we can’t sign them ourselves. But some will be available and perhaps looking for one last hurrah.
TAFKA The Oracle- Posts : 576
Join date : 2023-02-11
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
It has been rumoured we are signing Wyn Jones.
Given Dai likes to sign ex Turks, I would expect a couple. Baldwin was an unnecessary signing for me, especially as Flanagan knew what he was getting.
Of our leavers, I liked Sio when he was fit. I had a lot of time for Lonsdale and I actually liked Clark when he did get a shot. Bertranou was good too overall, but I am hoping Hope gets more opportunities and there was never going to be a place for Gonzo once Blacker was signed.
Given Dai likes to sign ex Turks, I would expect a couple. Baldwin was an unnecessary signing for me, especially as Flanagan knew what he was getting.
Of our leavers, I liked Sio when he was fit. I had a lot of time for Lonsdale and I actually liked Clark when he did get a shot. Bertranou was good too overall, but I am hoping Hope gets more opportunities and there was never going to be a place for Gonzo once Blacker was signed.
RiscaGame- Moderator
- Posts : 5926
Join date : 2016-01-24
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
I think Conbeer needs a contract somewhere, good player.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Yeah looking at the list of leavers at the Scarlets, my worry is we are going to sign them. Conbeer wouldnt be the worst signing in the world but in all honesty we need forwards. Wyn Jones isnt the player he was so it would be silly to get him now. We do need props but ones that have a good track record at league level and will clock the minutes in the season.
In all honesty I would prefer us to get some reliable non welsh props, at least until we can bring some through our own academy. Welsh Props are gash at the moment and the good ones are going to the Premiership.
Sio was the only player i wish we would have kept as he wasnt actually that bad. We still have a load of guys I wouldnt be keeping at the region retained like Benjamin and Jordan Williams. Jordan does have skills and he might have been a good running 10 had they moved him there earlier in his career. The issue is he is a turnstyle in defence and you cant have that as a 15 in the modern game.
In all honesty I would prefer us to get some reliable non welsh props, at least until we can bring some through our own academy. Welsh Props are gash at the moment and the good ones are going to the Premiership.
Sio was the only player i wish we would have kept as he wasnt actually that bad. We still have a load of guys I wouldnt be keeping at the region retained like Benjamin and Jordan Williams. Jordan does have skills and he might have been a good running 10 had they moved him there earlier in his career. The issue is he is a turnstyle in defence and you cant have that as a 15 in the modern game.
Welshmushroom- Posts : 2552
Join date : 2011-08-09
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
AOB wasn’t in for long, but I was thinking how much better he was than Reed during that time. Reed isn’t cut out for this level. Our reserve front row got pumped at the scrum too, that was a bit of a surprise.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Arhip wasnt the best scrummaging prop when he was in his prime and that was before the SA teams joined. Martinez for such a big man and as a argentine prop you would expect the set piece to be very good. Both of those guys I dont think are good enough.
What last nights match showed was that Rhodri and Coleman didn't do to badly in the opening 50 at scrum time. Granted Coleman I'm still on the fence on. But what we do know is you do need 4 good props at this level. So given I'm not sure about Coleman we would need at least 2 tightheads and a loosehead to get anywhere near being a good side.
If Dai doesnt sort the pack out we will never know which of our backline players can cut it at this level. Reed at 22 is still young so I would probably give him another season before judging him at that level. But after next year if he doesn't perform I would probably be moving him on.
What last nights match showed was that Rhodri and Coleman didn't do to badly in the opening 50 at scrum time. Granted Coleman I'm still on the fence on. But what we do know is you do need 4 good props at this level. So given I'm not sure about Coleman we would need at least 2 tightheads and a loosehead to get anywhere near being a good side.
If Dai doesnt sort the pack out we will never know which of our backline players can cut it at this level. Reed at 22 is still young so I would probably give him another season before judging him at that level. But after next year if he doesn't perform I would probably be moving him on.
Welshmushroom- Posts : 2552
Join date : 2011-08-09
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
But I do hope Dai eventually realizes that the following should be moved on:-
Ashton Hewitt, Jordan Williams (the human turnstyle), Steff Hughes, Lydiate, Screech, Joe Davies, Arhip, Brown, Fairbrother, Benjamin, Reynolds, Martinez. Thats just the bare minimum.
Granted some of those recently signed new contracts so unlikely but that's at least 12 guys I would have moved on and probably a couple of more on top of that if I had my way.
The sad thing is if we could only sort some key positions out we could actually be a very good side. There are some excellent players in our team.
Ashton Hewitt, Jordan Williams (the human turnstyle), Steff Hughes, Lydiate, Screech, Joe Davies, Arhip, Brown, Fairbrother, Benjamin, Reynolds, Martinez. Thats just the bare minimum.
Granted some of those recently signed new contracts so unlikely but that's at least 12 guys I would have moved on and probably a couple of more on top of that if I had my way.
The sad thing is if we could only sort some key positions out we could actually be a very good side. There are some excellent players in our team.
Welshmushroom- Posts : 2552
Join date : 2011-08-09
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
You can’t really blame the forwards if your fly-half is always missing kicks, dropping the ball and not making an effort to tackle. He wasn’t good at U20s either and that’s usually a good indicator.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Yeah I dont think Reed will be the next messiah or anything but he is still young....if there was another young 10 on the horizon I would probably go that way but we dont have much kicking around in that position in wales at the moment.
My only point is we need to sort our set piece out, lineout and scrum at this level have to be solid. And at the moment we are not there. We need to at least be able to physically match teams in the pack because if we can do that we will win more games than we did this year.
On top of that we dont really have much carrying power.
I'll reserve judgement for now until I see what Dai does with the last of his recruitment over the summer.
My only point is we need to sort our set piece out, lineout and scrum at this level have to be solid. And at the moment we are not there. We need to at least be able to physically match teams in the pack because if we can do that we will win more games than we did this year.
On top of that we dont really have much carrying power.
I'll reserve judgement for now until I see what Dai does with the last of his recruitment over the summer.
Welshmushroom- Posts : 2552
Join date : 2011-08-09
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
He’s not even in between, he just isn’t good enough for this level. You can’t use the age excuse, you’re either good enough for pro rugby or you aren’t. Funny how many other 20 year olds elsewhere are making the step-up, yet in Wales we tend to persist with crap players and hope they come good.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Your probably right on Reed but I'd rather us persist with someone like him than say sign someone like Dan Evans. Given Dai's connection with the Scarlets I really hope were not in for another off season were we are picking up Scarlets players who dont cut it.....Id rather us go overseas if we have to.
Wilson is a quality signing for us, Funaki could be good potentially but the other 2 are not great pickups. So at this point Dai is 50/50 in the transfer market. If he doesnt do a good job in the market in the summer it wont matter if Reed is or isnt up to it at this level.
Wilson is a quality signing for us, Funaki could be good potentially but the other 2 are not great pickups. So at this point Dai is 50/50 in the transfer market. If he doesnt do a good job in the market in the summer it wont matter if Reed is or isnt up to it at this level.
Welshmushroom- Posts : 2552
Join date : 2011-08-09
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
We already signed Dan Evans. I hope we aren’t signing Dan Jones either, it’s rumoured that it’s Wyn Jones coming over, but as you say we probably need another two on each side before we start to compete. You’ll also note that Lonsdale was good again last night, bizarre to see him on his way imo. I also think Ospreys or Scarlets should pick up Sio, good player if fit and they need some depth there - we do too but he’s already leaving.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
My bad I meant Dan Jones
Welshmushroom- Posts : 2552
Join date : 2011-08-09
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Speaking of crap players how long will it take for someone at the Dragons to realize we cant play Jordan Williams at 15. He cant defend and that is not a quality a modern 15 can have these days.
Welshmushroom- Posts : 2552
Join date : 2011-08-09
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Wouldn't be the worst thing if Jordan Williams moved on, he hardly plays for us anyway. His defence is probably better than Reed's though. I still think it would be good to trial Dyer at full-back.
I see Oli Burrows is incoming, which probably means Bradley Roberts is off - he deserved more recognition but never got it. I'd prefer if he stayed and Benjamin was sent away, unlikely though.
I see Oli Burrows is incoming, which probably means Bradley Roberts is off - he deserved more recognition but never got it. I'd prefer if he stayed and Benjamin was sent away, unlikely though.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
The irony is Jordan might have made a good running 10 had they identified him there early enough in his career. They didn't and I always questioned if he had the top end gas at 15 for that position. Granted his tackling at 10 would have still been an issue but at 15 your last man usually needs to put down some big wingers and its an area he never really improved in over his career. I'm guessing he's on good money as well.
Burrows is a weird signing. Would have made sense if we were getting rid of a couple of hookers. I don't think its a position we needed but he was probably cheap. Maybe you are right and Roberts is off. Benjamin should also be cut loose.
I thought Dai said he is bringing 7 signings in. We're already up to 5. That's a problem because for me he needed to get at least 3 props in this summer. I just hope the next 2 signings are props if 7 is all we are signing.
Burrows is a weird signing. Would have made sense if we were getting rid of a couple of hookers. I don't think its a position we needed but he was probably cheap. Maybe you are right and Roberts is off. Benjamin should also be cut loose.
I thought Dai said he is bringing 7 signings in. We're already up to 5. That's a problem because for me he needed to get at least 3 props in this summer. I just hope the next 2 signings are props if 7 is all we are signing.
Welshmushroom- Posts : 2552
Join date : 2011-08-09
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Well we almost know our squad for next season. I do hope we let Lydiate, Arhip & Brown who we don't know about just yet are all let go. Hopefully he lets them go and we strengthen our probs.
I also hope Dai realizes playing our first team in the challenge cup is useless as we will never win it to gain Champions Cup entry that way. I'd much rather we use it for development next season and fringe squad players. Leave the first team to actually see if we can get higher up the league. I'd probably make sure our first team is playing 100% of our home games with a view to win those and then maybe play them for another 2-3 away games in the games we are targeting for away wins. Here is how I would be choosing our side next season based on what I have seen this year.
First Team
1. Rhodri Jones
2. Elliot Dee
3. Lloyd Fairbrother
4. Ben Carter
5. Steve Cummings
6. Aaron Wainwright
7. Taine Basham
8. Solomone Funaki
9. Dane Blacker
10. Angus O'Brien
11. Jared Rosser
12. Chris Hollis
13. Joe Westwood
14. Rio Dyer
15. Harry Wilson
16. Martinez
17. Coleman
18. Roberts (Assuming he isn't leaving)
19. Nott
20. Lewis-Hughes
21. Rhodri Williams
22. Cai Evans
23. Owen
Ideally I would love to see us bring at least a tighthead and a loosehead in so we can replace Coleman and Martinez in that starting 23.
For the challenge cup and unwinnable away games I would rest all the above and start with the below:-
1 Reynolds
2 Coghlan
3 Yeandle
4 Joe Davies
5 Screech
6 Woodman
7 Griffiths
8 Keddie
9 Hope
10 Reed
11 Ewan Rosser
12 Ackerman
13 Steff Hughes
14 Rees-Weldon
15 David Richards
16 Kelleher-Griffiths
17 Uwimana
18 Olliw Burrows
19 Caple
20 Young
21 Lloyd
22 Berry
23 Lacey
And Hewitt, Jordan Williams & Benjamin would be moved somewhere on loan because I hope we are not looking to keep them and hopefully some club would want them so we could get them out before the end of their contracts if they had better offers elsewhere.
I also hope Dai realizes playing our first team in the challenge cup is useless as we will never win it to gain Champions Cup entry that way. I'd much rather we use it for development next season and fringe squad players. Leave the first team to actually see if we can get higher up the league. I'd probably make sure our first team is playing 100% of our home games with a view to win those and then maybe play them for another 2-3 away games in the games we are targeting for away wins. Here is how I would be choosing our side next season based on what I have seen this year.
First Team
1. Rhodri Jones
2. Elliot Dee
3. Lloyd Fairbrother
4. Ben Carter
5. Steve Cummings
6. Aaron Wainwright
7. Taine Basham
8. Solomone Funaki
9. Dane Blacker
10. Angus O'Brien
11. Jared Rosser
12. Chris Hollis
13. Joe Westwood
14. Rio Dyer
15. Harry Wilson
16. Martinez
17. Coleman
18. Roberts (Assuming he isn't leaving)
19. Nott
20. Lewis-Hughes
21. Rhodri Williams
22. Cai Evans
23. Owen
Ideally I would love to see us bring at least a tighthead and a loosehead in so we can replace Coleman and Martinez in that starting 23.
For the challenge cup and unwinnable away games I would rest all the above and start with the below:-
1 Reynolds
2 Coghlan
3 Yeandle
4 Joe Davies
5 Screech
6 Woodman
7 Griffiths
8 Keddie
9 Hope
10 Reed
11 Ewan Rosser
12 Ackerman
13 Steff Hughes
14 Rees-Weldon
15 David Richards
16 Kelleher-Griffiths
17 Uwimana
18 Olliw Burrows
19 Caple
20 Young
21 Lloyd
22 Berry
23 Lacey
And Hewitt, Jordan Williams & Benjamin would be moved somewhere on loan because I hope we are not looking to keep them and hopefully some club would want them so we could get them out before the end of their contracts if they had better offers elsewhere.
Welshmushroom- Posts : 2552
Join date : 2011-08-09
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
I’m inclined to agree with prioritising the league, not sure if Dai will see it that way and he’s still coming across poorly in interviews. If we want to get better then Rhodri Jones can’t be our first choice LH. He’s been around teams for years, always pretty average and never really got better. Him getting bumped off by a winger in Glasgow was the final nail in the coffin for me. I still think we need a bigger blindside, whether it be Nott or Carter, with Funaki at 8 with Waino or Basham at 7. Wainwright started as a 7 and I feel it’s potentially our strongest back-row, Dai’s probably too afraid to try it. Fair play for putting a decent player at 15 (Rosser), it’s about time. I’d still like to see Rio trialled there, and would like to see him and both Rossers on the pitch more often. Agree with changing the centres, Owen and Hughes aren’t that good unless they’re playing against slow centres like from the Ospreys. If we are keeping Hollis I’d have him on the bench though, and I’m still unsure about him but as I alluded to previously, it’s difficult to impress for a team like Dragons at this end of the season. Westwood might be seen as more of a 12 but I’m open to him playing about a bit until we know more. Wilson can probably play 12 and 12 quite well.
I’m worried about fly-half with Reed and Evans expected to play there. The second team looks atrocious but that’s our squad I guess. We need a 10, LH, TH, lock and some decent coaches. I’m not sure if any of this will happen.
I’m worried about fly-half with Reed and Evans expected to play there. The second team looks atrocious but that’s our squad I guess. We need a 10, LH, TH, lock and some decent coaches. I’m not sure if any of this will happen.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
mikey_dragon wrote:
I’m worried about fly-half with Reed and Evans expected to play there. The second team looks atrocious but that’s our squad I guess. We need a 10, LH, TH, lock and some decent coaches. I’m not sure if any of this will happen.
Yes and id only keep the senior ones in that second team until their contracts expire. Your list of positions looks about right. But I reckon at best we probably are getting 2 of those positions and im not even optimistic about that.
Welshmushroom- Posts : 2552
Join date : 2011-08-09
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Mefin Davies and Luke Narraway have left the coaching team.
TAFKA The Oracle- Posts : 576
Join date : 2023-02-11
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
I'm guessing their deals expired and Dai wants to get other people in. Cant imagine Dragons have the cash to start removing coaches early at this point.
Wonder who will come in now and if they will be any good.
I'm still concerned we have had no news on props yet. Please tell me Dai that you are at least bring 2 props in and letting Brown go. We need some durable ones that will play 12-14 games a season for about 50 mins a match.
Wonder who will come in now and if they will be any good.
I'm still concerned we have had no news on props yet. Please tell me Dai that you are at least bring 2 props in and letting Brown go. We need some durable ones that will play 12-14 games a season for about 50 mins a match.
Welshmushroom- Posts : 2552
Join date : 2011-08-09
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
I get a funny feeling we’ll go in for Wyn Jones. Lots being made about him being back to fitness for the first time in years, etc. I’m dead against it as I feel the Scarlets would have kept him if he was still up to it. But it’s got classic Dragons signing written all over it, and we need props, etc. I keep excepting to see it announced any day now!
TAFKA The Oracle- Posts : 576
Join date : 2023-02-11
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
I don’t know about Narraway, but Davies has been living a charmed existence for us. Ceri Jones was better before they got shot of him.
I think we are signing Wyn Jones too
I think we are signing Wyn Jones too
RiscaGame- Moderator
- Posts : 5926
Join date : 2016-01-24
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
All we’ve done is progress Sam Hobbs to forward coach too, by the looks. Which is still mad.
RiscaGame- Moderator
- Posts : 5926
Join date : 2016-01-24
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
RiscaGame wrote:All we’ve done is progress Sam Hobbs to forward coach too, by the looks. Which is still mad.
Really? Oh that's not going to end well. He needs a calibre proven forwards coach. Hobbs didn't even do that well as a prop at the highest level so not sure he will be up to the standard required.
I do wish with these project coaches we would spend more time farming them overseas for training so they could get a full range of experience to see how other countries coach before jetting them into our regional teams. It's one of my pet peeves and I am more than ever sure our coaching at regional level has not been good enough.
Maybe Hobbs has been sent to these places but there's been nothing I can find on that but happy to retract if i am wrong on that one.
Welshmushroom- Posts : 2552
Join date : 2011-08-09
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
RiscaGame wrote:I think we are signing Wyn Jones too
Oh please say it isn't true - Exactly the sort of Prop we don't need right now. Plus he is a Loosehead. We need at least 2 Tighthead Dai!!!! If you want to get off the bottom of the table that is.....
Welshmushroom- Posts : 2552
Join date : 2011-08-09
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Sordoni from Glasgow or some other 20 stone prop who will play 15 games for us, is what we need.
Welshmushroom- Posts : 2552
Join date : 2011-08-09
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Welshmushroom wrote:RiscaGame wrote:I think we are signing Wyn Jones too
Oh please say it isn't true - Exactly the sort of Prop we don't need right now. Plus he is a Loosehead. We need at least 2 Tighthead Dai!!!! If you want to get off the bottom of the table that is.....
And 2 LHs…
I think we may take a look at Morris, perhaps he’ll be ok an academy contract. We’ve already seen Kelleher-Griffiths and like Reed, he isn’t good enough for this level.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Wyn Jones was a Lion and perhaps is in a higher wage bracket. Scarlets and probably the rest of the Welsh teams can’t afford that right now. He would have been a better fit at Ospreys. Wyn should look for a contract in France. It’s not going to look good if Dai brings him to Dragons, as we’re pretty much stuck with his mate Hughes now who seems undroppable.
We still need a lock but I doubt that’s happening as I think Screech was re-signed. You see Sharks are adding Jason Jenkins to their ranks and I think Schickerling is heading back to Stormers with Kitshoff. It’s also well documented who Leinster are bringing in. I think next season could be worse for Welsh teams.
We still need a lock but I doubt that’s happening as I think Screech was re-signed. You see Sharks are adding Jason Jenkins to their ranks and I think Schickerling is heading back to Stormers with Kitshoff. It’s also well documented who Leinster are bringing in. I think next season could be worse for Welsh teams.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
So I think it probably may be worse but less about the actual money we have on player budget and more to do with most of the welsh sides really dont know how to make the correct signings and I have serious question marks on some of the coaching as well.
My main gripe is that they are still signing and coaching like teams would have done pre URC (South Africa joining). The league the last 3 seasons has changed a lot. Teams before that could get away with weaker set piece but in my opinion the platform is critical in this league now. A tight 5 and a solid 10 at least allows teams to play 10 man rugby (and while that is not fun to watch) it does result in closer games and more wins. There are other issues but the above 2 points really are the basis where most the welsh teams are falling over. You only have to look at the Ospreys. Solid set piece. Not a great attacking game in the backline but managed to win half their games and got close on others too. Blues, Scarlets and Dragons havent even recruited to cover a fundamental of the game (granted there are still some signings to be announced).
My main gripe is that they are still signing and coaching like teams would have done pre URC (South Africa joining). The league the last 3 seasons has changed a lot. Teams before that could get away with weaker set piece but in my opinion the platform is critical in this league now. A tight 5 and a solid 10 at least allows teams to play 10 man rugby (and while that is not fun to watch) it does result in closer games and more wins. There are other issues but the above 2 points really are the basis where most the welsh teams are falling over. You only have to look at the Ospreys. Solid set piece. Not a great attacking game in the backline but managed to win half their games and got close on others too. Blues, Scarlets and Dragons havent even recruited to cover a fundamental of the game (granted there are still some signings to be announced).
Welshmushroom- Posts : 2552
Join date : 2011-08-09
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Welshmushroom wrote:So I think it probably may be worse but less about the actual money we have on player budget and more to do with most of the welsh sides really dont know how to make the correct signings and I have serious question marks on some of the coaching as well.
My main gripe is that they are still signing and coaching like teams would have done pre URC (South Africa joining). The league the last 3 seasons has changed a lot. Teams before that could get away with weaker set piece but in my opinion the platform is critical in this league now. A tight 5 and a solid 10 at least allows teams to play 10 man rugby (and while that is not fun to watch) it does result in closer games and more wins. There are other issues but the above 2 points really are the basis where most the welsh teams are falling over. You only have to look at the Ospreys. Solid set piece. Not a great attacking game in the backline but managed to win half their games and got close on others too. Blues, Scarlets and Dragons havent even recruited to cover a fundamental of the game (granted there are still some signings to be announced).
Yep, spot on. I don't think I can imagine seeing Watkin in a Wales jersey again... he's probably the most limited centre in Europe, and his supposed strength (defence) isn't that good either.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
mikey_dragon wrote:Welshmushroom wrote:So I think it probably may be worse but less about the actual money we have on player budget and more to do with most of the welsh sides really dont know how to make the correct signings and I have serious question marks on some of the coaching as well.
My main gripe is that they are still signing and coaching like teams would have done pre URC (South Africa joining). The league the last 3 seasons has changed a lot. Teams before that could get away with weaker set piece but in my opinion the platform is critical in this league now. A tight 5 and a solid 10 at least allows teams to play 10 man rugby (and while that is not fun to watch) it does result in closer games and more wins. There are other issues but the above 2 points really are the basis where most the welsh teams are falling over. You only have to look at the Ospreys. Solid set piece. Not a great attacking game in the backline but managed to win half their games and got close on others too. Blues, Scarlets and Dragons havent even recruited to cover a fundamental of the game (granted there are still some signings to be announced).
Yep, spot on. I don't think I can imagine seeing Watkin in a Wales jersey again... he's probably the most limited centre in Europe, and his supposed strength (defence) isn't that good either.
He’ll be in the squad for SA game and/or the summer tour to Oz, I’m sure.
TAFKA The Oracle- Posts : 576
Join date : 2023-02-11
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
The problem we have is that we’re shopping in the bargain bucket. Pay peanuts, get monkeys, and all that. But then don’t expect to be competing higher up the league and in the knockout stages of cup comps.
WM, you say about the coaches not being able to make the correct signings. When you’re literally fishing about at the bottom of the barrel it’s inevitable that you will need to take a punt on players who are unknown or have question marks over them in terms of fitness, form, motivation, etc. All the best players can demand wages that we cannot afford. So we end up with with the ones no one else wants. Or the ones others are not prepared to take a risk on, because they don’t need to because they can pay top dollar for proven performers!
We also, unfortunately, can’t afford lots of marquee players. Even if we got someone like Beauden Barrett I reckon we’d still be poor. Maybe a bit better but not much change in league position. Because 1 man can’t do it all. He plays in tops teams with world class players all around him. An armchair ride. Again, which we can’t afford. So the only hope is to keep making signings that have some potential (like the ones we’ve done), get the high wage earners who are pretty ineffective off the wage bill (like we’ve been doing to a certain extent), and hope that the stars align and they all turn out to be better than what they’ve replaced. A tough ask when some of the guys they’re replacing are the likes of Rowlands and Moriarty!
WM, you say about the coaches not being able to make the correct signings. When you’re literally fishing about at the bottom of the barrel it’s inevitable that you will need to take a punt on players who are unknown or have question marks over them in terms of fitness, form, motivation, etc. All the best players can demand wages that we cannot afford. So we end up with with the ones no one else wants. Or the ones others are not prepared to take a risk on, because they don’t need to because they can pay top dollar for proven performers!
We also, unfortunately, can’t afford lots of marquee players. Even if we got someone like Beauden Barrett I reckon we’d still be poor. Maybe a bit better but not much change in league position. Because 1 man can’t do it all. He plays in tops teams with world class players all around him. An armchair ride. Again, which we can’t afford. So the only hope is to keep making signings that have some potential (like the ones we’ve done), get the high wage earners who are pretty ineffective off the wage bill (like we’ve been doing to a certain extent), and hope that the stars align and they all turn out to be better than what they’ve replaced. A tough ask when some of the guys they’re replacing are the likes of Rowlands and Moriarty!
TAFKA The Oracle- Posts : 576
Join date : 2023-02-11
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
TAFKA The Oracle wrote:mikey_dragon wrote:Welshmushroom wrote:So I think it probably may be worse but less about the actual money we have on player budget and more to do with most of the welsh sides really dont know how to make the correct signings and I have serious question marks on some of the coaching as well.
My main gripe is that they are still signing and coaching like teams would have done pre URC (South Africa joining). The league the last 3 seasons has changed a lot. Teams before that could get away with weaker set piece but in my opinion the platform is critical in this league now. A tight 5 and a solid 10 at least allows teams to play 10 man rugby (and while that is not fun to watch) it does result in closer games and more wins. There are other issues but the above 2 points really are the basis where most the welsh teams are falling over. You only have to look at the Ospreys. Solid set piece. Not a great attacking game in the backline but managed to win half their games and got close on others too. Blues, Scarlets and Dragons havent even recruited to cover a fundamental of the game (granted there are still some signings to be announced).
Yep, spot on. I don't think I can imagine seeing Watkin in a Wales jersey again... he's probably the most limited centre in Europe, and his supposed strength (defence) isn't that good either.
He’ll be in the squad for SA game and/or the summer tour to Oz, I’m sure.
Yep, and another one of many reasons clueless Gatland needs to go.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
TAFKA The Oracle likes this post
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Tafka - i dont agree with that but only because what is going on elsewhere. Most Premiership sides have similar budgets, not to mention we are for the first time on comparable spends as the other 3 regions. If Ospreys can put a team that can win half their games I dont accept our current loss ratio. At the very least we should be winning more of our home games.
I understand the sentiment of shopping at the bottom, which is true, but having coaches who have no track records of shrewd signings is my point with this. Booth is way ahead of the other 3 coaches in terms of building his teams with a combination of development and clever signings.
I'd also point to Connacht as well. They have for years managed to sign clever transfers and outperformed most of the regions with comparable spends.
I refuse to believe this is anything other than a head coach issue. If anything there probably hasn't been a better market in the last decade for picking up gems. I will concede that would involve having to max out the overseas cap for the regions because currently there are no credible welsh options to be competitive next season.
I understand the sentiment of shopping at the bottom, which is true, but having coaches who have no track records of shrewd signings is my point with this. Booth is way ahead of the other 3 coaches in terms of building his teams with a combination of development and clever signings.
I'd also point to Connacht as well. They have for years managed to sign clever transfers and outperformed most of the regions with comparable spends.
I refuse to believe this is anything other than a head coach issue. If anything there probably hasn't been a better market in the last decade for picking up gems. I will concede that would involve having to max out the overseas cap for the regions because currently there are no credible welsh options to be competitive next season.
Welshmushroom- Posts : 2552
Join date : 2011-08-09
Re: Dragons RFC - new name, new season: 2022/23
Ospreys no longer have Smith or Francis. Their first choice front 5 is good but behind that, they’ll really struggle. They’ll be losing the most forwards to Wales (when Gatland sorts out his marbles), it’s surprising that they are not looking to strengthen those areas with some experience from overseas. It would also be a good move imo if they picked up Sio from us, would add something decent to their backline and can play on the wing. Conbeer would be a good addition for them too. I doubt this will happen, plus there is the persistence with Watkin and Morgan in the backline, so it’s not all roses down there.
Agree on Connacht, they seem to do well with what they have. You’ll note that they have two front-row’s capable of competing in the URC, another key difference.
Agree on Connacht, they seem to do well with what they have. You’ll note that they have two front-row’s capable of competing in the URC, another key difference.
mikey_dragon- Posts : 15543
Join date : 2015-07-25
Age : 35
Page 8 of 11 • 1, 2, 3 ... 7, 8, 9, 10, 11
Similar topics
» RL season 2022
» URC Season 2022/23
» Leinster Rugby 2022/23 Season
» URC Season Review 2022/23
» Season 2021 / 2022 - Hopes and Expectations...
» URC Season 2022/23
» Leinster Rugby 2022/23 Season
» URC Season Review 2022/23
» Season 2021 / 2022 - Hopes and Expectations...
The v2 Forum :: Sport :: Rugby Union :: Club Rugby
Page 8 of 11
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|