Worst 10 of the Six Nations (ever)

Since the Six Nations started in 2000. Who has been the worst 10?

David Humphreys? Seriously? Do you actually know anything about rugby? About half of Irish fans demanded he play instead of O'Gara for half of the decade.

Arwel Thomas has to have a mention.

Hookisms and Hyperbole wrote:David Humphreys? Seriously? Do you actually know anything about rugby? About half of Irish fans demanded he play instead of O'Gara for half of the decade.

No, he doesn't.

Neil Jenkins wtf.

Maybe Goode or Parks from your list.

Wow, simply wow. There are some very good 10's in that list that you compiled to be the worst ever....

Humphreys was one of the best Ireland ever produced...
Jenkins was the first to break 1000 international points...

I am not going to comment further....

I agree with EireBilly

nuff said

I am not saying Humphreys was bad, just naming a lot of 10's to give people more choice.

Toby Flood Dublin 2011 would be near the top.

Some very good tens in that list.

gnollbeast wrote:I am not saying Humphreys was bad, just naming a lot of 10's to give people more choice.

Its a poll for the WORST 10's in the 6N right?

I am really missing something here if you name great players in a worst of poll........

I didn't even see Neil Jenkins! You shouldn't be allowed near a keyboard. I hope George North eats your fingers

Did Lamaison actually play in the 6N much? or indeed Jenkins? Thought they were more from the 90s. From that list Goode, Harris and Pez were pretty awful.

I voted for Neil jenkins just to shake things up a bit. It's a shame Johnny Wilkinson isn't on the list, now that would create some debate.

Italy have had a few dubious selections at 10 over the years - probably the one position where on-going weakness has let them down since Dominguez's retirement.
At least they didn't try Bergomasco there...

Who voted for Christophe Lamaison?!

Why does the 6 nations bring out all the bandwagon trolls?

.

Toby Flood Dublin 2011 would be near the top.

As off form as he was then that's still better than Barkley was at 10.

luckless_pedestrian wrote:Don't like the competition eh, Hersh?

If you took the time to read what I typed once in a while you would soon realise that I know what I'm talking about.

Iestyn Harris should never have made it into the national side. His first game of professional union, he threw the ball deliberately into touch (Cardiff V Llanelli), and the ref said something along the lines of 'oh, you didn't know that was against the rules, ok then its a lineout, but remember not to do it again.'

.

luckless_pedestrian wrote:I know you know your rugby, Hersh. What I don't understand is why you don't stick to rugby instead of trying to wind people up.

I haven't wummed anyone for a why, can we stay on topic please.

Fair dos. I'll edit my comments.

so this is a slate dan parks poll is it?

Apparently not, strokey, more of a slate Iestyn Harris and Gavin Henson poll - I blame the OP personally

I think the OP was planning a well disguised "Slate on Dan Parks"

That is why he brought so many other "weak" players in.

Sadly it backfired.

Is it in any way apt that the OP (beast)'s moniker rhymes with troll?

Got to be Ramiro Pez for me. At least the others shine for their clubs.

How did it backfire on my? You lot have been bickering for ages!

AsLongAsBut100ofUs wrote:Apparently not, strokey, more of a slate Iestyn Harris and Gavin Henson poll - I blame the OP personally

biltongbek wrote:
I think the OP was planning a well disguised "Slate on Dan Parks"

That is why he brought so many other "weak" players in.

Sadly it backfired.

how do you get two quotes in one comment??
fixed the html for you - KRD

formerly known as Sam wrote:

Toby Flood Dublin 2011 would be near the top.

As off form as he was then that's still better than Barkley was at 10.

Barkley was good at 10 in 2003 RWC to be fair to him

cheers KRD- however - how do you do it?

Bathite wrote:

formerly known as Sam wrote:

Toby Flood Dublin 2011 would be near the top.

As off form as he was then that's still better than Barkley was at 10.

Barkley was good at 10 in 2003 RWC to be fair to him

2007. Didn't he have one game against USA where he did ok (stood out in a poor team)

Barkley did play well at FH against USA, then got injured for the game against SA (which featured Catt and Farell as a 10-12 partnership), returned to play IC for a couple of matches (not very well either) before getting injured again. So yeah, one good game at 10.

mystiroakey wrote:cheers KRD- however - how do you do it?

Adding a second quote without naming the person you're quoting is easy, highlight your quote and click the speech bubble button above the editor.

To include a name you have to put in some html coding

xyz wrote:
Testing here

is coded as
[_quote="xyz"]
Testing here
[/quote_]
with the underscores ("_") removed

Kiwireddevil wrote:

mystiroakey wrote:cheers KRD- however - how do you do it?

Adding a second quote without naming the person you're quoting is easy, highlight your quote and click the speech bubble button above the editor.

To include a name you have to put in some html coding

xyz wrote:
Testing here

is coded as
[_quote="xyz"]
Testing here
[/quote_]
with the underscores ("_") removed

thanks

HERSH wrote:Why does the 6 nations bring out all the bandwagon trolls?

probably because Wales and England play in it.

I went for Iestyn Harris even though I felt he was chucked in far too early and had way too much pressure on.

I went for iestyn but thinking about it, I reckon Goode's boredom inducing style combined with his 52 inch waist probably snatch it. Either way both of them were far worse than parks.

andy goodes eyebrows frightened me

pez worst of that bunch. honourable mention to henson for that performance in Landsdowne. Hilarious. He got a right old ribbing from the crowd that day and melted.

humphreys, jenkins, merceron. you are having a laugh

Danny Cipriani surely !! what a royal mincer and the slowest person to kick a ball ever.