Greatest Premiership Goalkeeper

Thanks to those who voted

The Nominations are

Peter Schmeichel
Former Man United Player
Former Aston Villa Player
Former Man City Player

Edwin Van Der Sar
Former Fulham Player
Former Man United Player

John Ruddy
Former Everton Goalkeeper
Current Norwich Goalkeeper

Rob Green 
Former Norwich Goalkeeper
Former West Ham Goalkeeper
Current QPR Goalkeeper

David Seaman
Former Arsenal Goalkeeper
Former Man City Goalkeeper

Peter Cech
Current Chelsea Goalkeeper

Pepe Reina
Former Liverpool Goalkeeper

Rob green and John ruddy.....

lol surely David James and Nigel Martyn are better than rob green and john ruddy

Voted for David Seaman. He's English and....well he's English. Superb shot-stopper, one of Arsenal's greatest ever players. Yeah, has to be Seaman.

Peter Schmeichel without a doubt. Best goalkeeper I have ever seen, the only goalie who ever came close was Neville Southall imo. A lot of United fans do seem to think van Der Sar was on a par with Schmeichel though. Nigel Martyn was awesome too.

Very strange to have Rob Green and John Ruddy in there, although I do think Ruddy is a good keeper.

Jeez Nick some strange choices...

Ruddy and Green are hair-brained entrants based on Olly mentioning them on the other thread, but they have no place here...

Surely Friedel, Schwarzer, Southall, Given, James are all more worthy of consideration. Hell, I'd have Ed De Goey above John Ruddy.

Id love to vote for you Rob but Peter Schmeichel is the pinnacle of goalkeeping

You do realise Nick didn't choose these, that it's based on what we sent...?

If you wanted a certain goalkeeper to get a mention, why didn't you nominate them?

Has to be Schmeichel, he revolutionised goalkeeping to an extent with is distribution. Would have loved to have voted for Seaman, but Schmeichel was on a different level.

Crimey wrote:You do realise Nick didn't choose these, that it's based on what we sent...?

If you wanted a certain goalkeeper to get a mention, why didn't you nominate them?

I don't know what you're talking about. Thats why I didn't nominate.

Nominate where?

MIG wrote:

Crimey wrote:You do realise Nick didn't choose these, that it's based on what we sent...?

If you wanted a certain goalkeeper to get a mention, why didn't you nominate them?

I don't know what you're talking about.  Thats why I didn't nominate.

Nominate where?

https://www.606v2.com/t46760-greatest-premiership-moments

Second to last post, Nick asked people to PM him their nominations. This is a long list of polls that he is going to do.

Sorry Nick, i don't think i sent my nominations over in the end last night i forgot, i will do my best to send in my nominations for the future polls.

I appreciate Peter's probably the better goalkeeper but van der Sar is my favourite goalie ever so he gets my vote. He's certainly a "great" in my eyes (ok that sounds a bit fangirlish).

Schmeichel was superb but was prone to a lob. Seaman on the other hand couldn't save anything from 25 yards out or more. VDS and Cech were are my choices.

Could everyone now send me in votes for Greatest Premiership Defender.

Remember 2 votes per person 

John Ruddy?! Eh? "the greatest goalkeeper".....jesus this board has seriously gone down the Poopie.

If that's the case id like to add the following who are clearly better than Ruddy:

Paul Robinson, David James, Neil Sullivan, Mark Schwarzer, Asmir Begovic, Tim Krul, Jens Lehman, Mark Bosnich, Neville Southall, Kasey Keller and errrrr Pavel Sernicek.

You could of voted ...

Sorry just realised. Ive voted now lol

Duty281 wrote:Voted for David Seaman. He's English and....well he's English. Superb shot-stopper, one of Arsenal's greatest ever players. Yeah, has to be Seaman.

Predictable

Ruddy and Green? LOL
Might as well have Massimo Taibi on that list.

Anyway, its a toss up between Schmeichel and Cech for me. I'd probably give the Dane the edge.

Special mentions to the likes of Friedel, Schwarzer, Given, Jaaskelainen etc who were all great long running servents for the Premiership.

TopHat24/7 wrote:

Duty281 wrote:Voted for David Seaman. He's English and....well he's English. Superb shot-stopper, one of Arsenal's greatest ever players. Yeah, has to be Seaman.

Predictable

Indeed it was old bean.