Pacquiao/Marquez - Good Win Or Great Win?

It is clear that both are fading forces, but still do have a fair amount to give and both are still clearly around the top of the sport.

However, I began thinking to myself, if Marquez were to beat the All Time Great Pacquiao at this stage of his career, with Manny seemingly more and more disinterested with the sport, and recent performances looking worse and worse with the added factor that Manny is now coming off a loss (Contentious as it may be) would a win over him now be in the "Great win" category, or in your view now has Manny fizzled out enough and would it now miss out and hit the "Good win" category?

Alternatively, a win for Manny against a (39?) year old Marquez who has seemingly struggled slightly more and more with the bigger opposition now not classed as such a great win for Manny? Again is this merely a good win, or is it in your opinion still a great win?

Thoughts?

He's beaten him thrice already This will just be another time if he wins.

Think it's a great win for either to be fair, two top 10 P4P, both evenly matched and serve up a classic, can't believe many are calling the fight pointless, thought Manny would've choose the easier option in Bradley

Cheers

Rodders

Marquez can't win by decision...end of..

Arum promotes..Arum still has eyes on a 100 million showdown with Floyd..

If you can't win when you win ten rounds then you never will..

would be a good win i feel.
Allegedly their both going for a stoppage this time...could be saving the best for last!
Doubt it though

TRUSSMAN66 wrote:Marquez can't win by decision...end of..

Arum promotes..Arum still has eyes on a 100 million showdown with Floyd..

If you can't win when you win ten rounds then you never will..

I would've agreed with you Truss until Pac was shafted in the Bradley fight

I think it'd be symbolic rather than 'good' or 'great'.

Rodney wrote:Think it's a great win for either to be fair, two top 10 P4P, both evenly matched and serve up a classic, can't believe many are calling the fight pointless, thought Manny would've choose the easier option in Bradley

Cheers

Rodders

Clearly only likes the scew-jobs going one way.....