Man City v Man Utd semi – the Neutrals view?

I would like to put this out to fans of other teams rather than Utd & City fans. Who would you rather win the semi?

City

No diggidy

I live in Manchester and Radio Manchester were really annoying when they announced it as a Manchester Derby before the City game had even been played!

im a united fan so im biased, i bet alot of neutrals would like neither. theres always been alot of ABU (anyone but united) due to our success and fergies fantastic ability to rub people up the wrong way. but surely many people cant wannt see citys mercanaries do well? at least when we have spent money its down to the success rather than being a suger daddys toy

Don't think there is such thing as neutral where Utd are concerned. You love 'em or hate 'em

well I just hope City beats Utd.

i would like man u to win

Toon Lass wrote:i would like man u to win

always knew the geordies had good taste

Thought this was amusing on the Beeb site:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/thefootballtacticsblog/2011/04/who_would_make_your_all-time_m.html

All time Utd and City combined team.

Colin Bell is pretty much the only City player in it (Denis Law is also there) and is he really ahead of Roy Keane or Bryan Robson?
Also no Giggs?

Hero wrote:Thought this was amusing on the Beeb site:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/thefootballtacticsblog/2011/04/who_would_make_your_all-time_m.html

All time Utd and City combined team.

Colin Bell is pretty much the only City player in it (Denis Law is also there) and is he really ahead of Roy Keane or Bryan Robson?
Also no Giggs?

It was a bit of a suck up to City that selection. At the end of the day, City have had some great players, but not one of them has been better than a United player in the same position. The only one you could ever possibly go for is Trautmann, and that's based on legend.

trautmann was never the best keeper in the world, unlike both schmeichel and van der saar. there wouldnt be a single city player in my team and thats not be being biased (unless you count law but he clearly was more of a united player). simple facts are united have dominated english football like city never have

Dennis Tuarte was a fantastic player!

I'd like to see City win because I don't think 1 team winning all the trophies is good for football, alro the City fans deserve it for their loyalty, Utd are better badder and stronger tho

We were utterly rudey poo today. Really, really bad after 30 minutes. Just no attacking intent to us at all. A Nani free kick was our best chance after half an hour; that says it all.

Berbatov missed two sitters in a minute, cant believe he couldn't net that second one