Week 10 Results

Voter 1

PSV vs Atlanta
Team 4-7
Tactics and Formation 3-6
Substitutes 2-1
+ 2 for Home Team
= 11-14

Decent PSV side which for me is a bit under-rated in this league. Would like to see a bit of a freshen up though, both in terms of players and tactics.
As for Atlanta, I Would prefer Rashford drifting left rather than right, but it's obviously a great attack. I'd question if Montolivo is still good enough, and Thiago Silva should be in the middle of the three for me.
The Atlanta wing backs and front two give them the edge and it's a shame that we haven't seen some sort of tactics to counter them, as if we did I could have easily given PSV something.

Voter 2

Team: PSV 5 – Atalanta 6
Tactics & formation: 4 – 5
Subs: Team 1 – 2
+2 points for home team
Total: 12 - 13

Voter 3

PSV - Atalanta

Team: 5-6
Tactics: 4-5
Subs: 2-1
Home: 2-0
Result: 13-12

Voter 4

PSV 4 Atalanta 7
T&F - PSV 4 Atalanta 5
Subs - PSV 1 Atalanta 2
+2pts home advantage PSV
PSV 11 Atalanta 14


Voter 5

Team: PSV 4 – 7 Atalanta
Tactics & formation: PSV 5 – 4 Atalanta
Subs: PSV 1 – 2 Atalanta
+2 points for home team
Total: PSV 12 – 13 Atalanta


Voter 6

Team: 6-5
Tactics & formation: 5-4
Subs: 1-2
+2 points for home team
Total: 14-11

Voter 1

Team: Leipzig 7 – Watford 4
Tactics & formation: 4 – 5
Subs: Team 1 – 2
+2 points for home team
Total: 14 - 11

Voter 2

Leipzig - Watford
Team: 6-5
Tactics: 4-5
Subs: 2-1
Home: 2-0
Result: 14-11

Voter 3

Team: Leipzig 7 – 4 Watford
Tactics & formation: Leipzig 4 – 5 Watford
Subs: Leipzig 1 – 2 Watford
+2 points for home team
Total: Team Leipzig 14 – 11 Watford

Voter 4

Team: 6-5
Tactics & formation: 4-5
Subs: 1-2
+2 points for home team
Total: 13-12

Voter 1

Swansea vs Nice
Team 4-7
Tactics and Formation 4-5
Substitutes 2-1
+ 2 for Home Team
= 12-13

Swansea need to be doing more than just starting the season. As I've said before, they've got some players I like. Llorente would give the Nice defense a 'Mere' (sorry!), and Sigurdsson and Oxlade can change games. Swansea need to upgrade defensively.
Nice have also some recycled tactics, but have some good talents in Bakayoko, Werner and Dembele who I would be making more crucial to the team and putting this more into the tactics.
Swansea get the edge on subs with Davies and Ayew coming on, which possibly scrapes them a draw in my book.

Voter 2

Team: Swansea 5 – Nice 6
Tactics & formation: 4 – 5
Subs: Team 2 – 1
+2 points for home team
Total: 13 - 12

Voter 3

Swansea - Nice

Team: 5-6
Tactics: 4-5
Subs: 2-1
Home: 2-0
Result: 13-12

Voter 4

Swansea 5 Nice 6
T&F - Swansea 4 Nice 5
Subs - Swansea 2 Nice 1
+2pts home advantage Swansea
Swansea 13 Nice 12

Voter 5

Team: 4-7
Tactics & formation: 2-7
Subs: 1-2
+2 Home ADV
Total: 9-16

Comments: Nice win this easily for me. Swansea need to sort themselves out, they have a lot of work to do and have been "starting the season" for around 5 weeks now. I have given this score simply because Nice are one of the best teams in the league and you can't just use the same tactics over and over and hope to win games in our league, especially against a title contender (this is the biggest score i have given and its for a reason)

Voter 1

Marseille vs Ajax
Team 5-6
Tactics and Formation 3-6
Substitutes 1-2
+ 2 for Home Team
= 11-14


A nicely written set of tactics from Marseille, but there's two questions fro me. Ajax are interchanging with attackers who like to move. Getting tight as Marseille's defense have been instructed to do would drag them out of position. I imagine Ajax pressing higher up the pitch too. A faster may have suited the home side better today. It's a good set of tactics from Ajax and a fantastic attack, but they do look suspect defensively and on another day I see them being got at.

Voter 2

Team: Marseille 5 – Ajax 6
Tactics & formation: 5 – 4
Subs: Team 2 – 1
+2 points for home team
Total: 14 - 11

Voter 3

Marseille 4 Ajax 7
T&F - Marseille 5 Ajax 4
Subs - Marseille 1 Ajax 2
+ 2pts home advantage Marseille
Marseille 12 Ajax 13

Voter 4

Team: Marseille 4 – 7 Ajax
Tactics & formation: Marseille 5 – 4 Ajax
Subs: Marseille 1 – 2 Ajax
+2 points for home team
Total: Marseille 12 – 13 Ajax