Worst player of the 6 nations so far

First topic message reminder :

There are a few quite obvious candidates:

Michelak had a brilliant AI campaign and everyone on 606v2 thought Lazarus was back from the dead. Didnt fool me though, he is a limited player. He even managed to fool the antipodeans into thinking he was world class.

Chris Ashton. Scored v Scotland but has been very weak since both in defense and attack. Probably wont be a Lion at this rate. Still more famous for his try celebrations than his all round game.

Sam Warburton has been way off his usual stellar form, so much so he lost the captaincy. Has turned it round though proving his character and that he isnt just a flash in the pan. Still he will be disapointed with his form.


France: Michelak
England: Ashsplash
Ireland: Declan Kidney. Sorry couldnt resist.
Italy:Giovanbattista Venditti. Anonymous throughout.
Wales: Warburton.
Scotland:Sean Lamont. Hamilton comes close.

For me the prize goes to Freddy. He has singlehandedly relegated a decent France team to the bottom of the pile.

Who do you think has been the worst player? Feel free to agree, disagree, write a poem, discuss the apointment of the first Jewish pope or vent etc.

LondonTiger wrote:For me, though it saddens it to say it, but since the France game Castro has been really poor for Italy.

He has not been himself but in fairness he was clearly carrying an injury which finally did for him in the last game.

Taffineastbourne wrote:

LondonTiger wrote:For me, though it saddens it to say it, but since the France game Castro has been really poor for Italy.

He has not been himself but in fairness he was clearly carrying an injury which finally did for him in the last game.

He has, but really he has not been quite right all season. He is still a hero in our household though