Current British P4P Top 10 - From Sky Sports

First topic message reminder :

From last month on Sky Sports.


http://www1.skysports.com/boxing/news/11067/8708698/british-p4p-rankings



1.Carl Froch

2.Ricky Burns

3.David Haye

4.Amir Khan

5.Nathan Cleverly

6.Jamie McDonnell

7.Matthew Macklin

8.Martin Murray

9.Kell Brook

10.Scott Quigg

Let's be honest, there isn't a lot between these guys, save for Carl Froch.

Khan has decent wins over Judah, Maidana, Malignaggi. The Peterson fiasco should be discarded.

Burns has the wins over Katsidis, Mitchell, Moses and Martinez.

Both looked poor last time out.

Cleverly has a chance to put himself back on track against Kovalev.

Yes, Khan has - enough for top10. Not for top2. List is pointless and ridiculous otherwise - I reiterate my point about having Hatton in it if that's the way you're doing things.

hatton's last win was some time a go Mate.......You're reaching there....

Khan wouldn't be in my top 2.....close.........

His ledger is impressive and he's still a top fighter.....that Burns can only dream of aspiring to be..at the moment.

To be honest what does Haye have on the plus side to be ranked so highly. His wins (Chisora, Harrison, Ruiz, Valuev) are hardly the stuff of legends. Was beaten by the top man in almost every round.

Counting how many years ago the Valuev fight was, does a long lay off and a win against Chisora really justify such a high ranking?

Strongy has Macklin at 7......Is that justified...Or does the Irish flag have anything to do with it..

Honest answer please ??

Think somewhere between 7 and 10 is justifiable....

Are you serious..

Didn't say nailed on, just that you could probably find a way to justify it.

Truss, you seem to have some sort of delusion when it comes to were I am from.

I wouldn't have an Northern Irish or English (wannabe Irish) fighter anywhere near the top 10 at this moment in time. Yes Frampton may get there. But he is barely 15 fights in so can't view him as top 10.

Macklin? You must be kidding. He may have been top 10 about 2 years ago, but since then he has only won against Alcine in 1 round....other than that a (brave as some would describe it) showing against Martinez getting wore down and finished off like a wife who didnt have the dinner ready, and then mushed against GGG. No way he makes top 10. Barker is easily higher. He has looked alright since the Martinez fight.

You've just been hammering Khan for losing two of his last major fights and Khan has an impressive ledger..

and you have Macklin 7-10 and his last two big fights have been slaps...

Come on Mate.....up your game !!!

You do know that a ranking of 10 is worse than a ranking of 5, right??

Yes but what has Macklin got in his win column to counter his losses.....and Golotkin/Martinez were worse than Garcia and the pED man...right??

I thought Tony Bellew would have been top 10 on their list.

Carl Frampton

Paul McCloskey

Brian Magee

Martin Lindsey

Martin Rogan

Ryan Burnett

Joe Rea

Luke Wilton

Andy Lee

Eamonn O'Kane

Cant argue with that list can you Truss  

You're wumming....Can't believe you'd have Lee so low!!

He struggles with Anthony Fitzgerald and the Vera loss years and years ago has to be viewed upon, plus hes a dirtball.

Michael Collins had a decent record..Number 11 ??

Phil Collins had a decent record too

Theres something in the air tonight

Reborn-DeeMcK-Reborn wrote:Phil Collins had a decent record too

And a groovy kind of glove apparently......

Didn't want to retire apparently...

Wanted............One more night !!

Used to win........against all odds

Due to be on ringside with Adam smith and Jonny Nelson live in the sussudio this week......

He had a groovy kind of (g)Love....

Reborn-DeeMcK-Reborn wrote:He had a groovy kind of (g)Love....

Erm...... (scroll up  )

Ooooops :-s